Kangaroo Fact Check
The Kangaroo Industry Association of Australia has fact checked the main claims made in the documentary.
CLAIM 1: Loss of habitat, urban development, agricultural practices and continuing industrial-scale slaughter eliminate kangaroos across vast regions where historical records described them as once widespread and abundant.
PARTLY TRUE: While some kangaroo and wallaby species have declined in numbers due to the impact of humans on their habitats, other species have benefited and increased in population size. Only four species of kangaroo with large populations are permitted to be harvested — the Western grey kangaroo, Eastern grey kangaroo, Common wallaroo and Red kangaroo.
CLAIM 2: Kangaroos grow and breed slowly and have high juvenile mortality. For example, a Grey Kangaroo doe can produce up to eight joeys in her lifetime, with just two likely to survive to independence.
PARTLY TRUE: Female kangaroos breed slowly in drought conditions and continuously under good conditions. They can produce up to three young simultaneously at different stages of development. Most kangaroos mate within a few days of giving birth to ensure a new birth can occur very soon after the first young exits the pouch, taking advantage of good conditions. Grey kangaroos differ in that they tend to breed seasonally and, therefore, produce fewer young.
CLAIM 3: Maximum wild population growth rates average 10 per cent in optimal conditions, with annual declines of up to 60 per cent during drought recorded. It is biologically impossible for kangaroo populations to increase rapidly.
PARTLY TRUE: An average 10 per cent annual increase in kangaroo numbers could be considered rapid growth. A 10 per cent increase on 2016 population numbers of harvested species would equate to around 470 000 additional kangaroos. Existing populations of some species in certain areas are already considered to be unsustainable. CLAIM 4: Shooting quotas of 15–20 per cent or more of population estimates exceed actual kangaroo population growth rates.
FALSE: The commercial kangaroo harvest takes place under regulations that allow a quota of 10–20 per cent of the estimated population to be taken each year. The number of kangaroos that are actually harvested has been much less (around 65 per cent of the allowable quota) since 2001.
Harvesting quotas are set by state wildlife management agencies based on current population estimates as well as the modelled impact of current and projected climate on numbers to protect populations from over-harvesting.
CLAIM 5: Analysis shows critically flawed kangaroo survey methodologies systematically inflate population estimates from which commercial shooting quotas are then over-allocated.
FALSE: Population estimates are based on aerial and ground surveys in the areas within Australia where commercial harvesting occurs. The actual national populations would be significantly higher as these figures do not include estimates for areas not surveyed.
Quotas may be modified during the year based on seasonal conditions, the results of additional surveys and monitoring of the harvest throughout the year. Restrictions may be placed on the harvest such as closing certain areas down or placing weight and size limits on the animals entering the industry. CLAIM 6:
Consideration of commercial shooting impacts on kangaroo populations has never
included millions of kangaroos additionally shot by landowners and illegal shooting. Other major mortality factors are also ignored.
FALSE: Since the late 1970s, harvest quotas have been based upon population estimates obtained primarily from aerial surveys, with some consideration being given to factors such as overall population trends, climatic conditions and trends in various harvest statistics, including carcass weight, sex ratio, skin size and the size of the overall offtake. In its report entitled Review of Kangaroo
Management, March 1990, representatives of the US Fish and Wildlife Service found that: “Adequate legislation exists in all States and Territories of Australia for the protection of the Red kangaroo, the Eastern grey kangaroo and the Western grey kangaroo. There does not appear to be any large-scale illegal killing of kangaroos being conducted in any of the States of Australia having a commercial export kill quota for kangaroos.”
CLAIM 7: Government survey data and commercial shooting statistics illustrate declining populations and landscapes now significantly depleted of kangaroos. FALSE: Population estimates for the four harvested species fluctuated between 17 million and 57 million between 1980 and 2009. In 2016, the population in commercial harvest zones was estimated at 47.2 million.
CLAIM 8: Shooting occurs away from any scrutiny and in darkness when nonlethal shots are inevitable, often causing horrific injuries. Evidence suggests 4 to 40 per cent of commercially shot animals are not shot directly in the brain but in the neck or body. This equates to between 65 284 and 652 839 animals mis-shot in 2015. Unknown further numbers of mis-shot kangaroos are left to die in the field by commercial and non-commercial shooters.
FALSE: The harvest occurs at dusk and at night, because this is when kangaroos are most active. Shooters are skilled and licenced professionals with a high accuracy rate. About 97 per cent of all kangaroos targeted by professional harvesters were killed instantaneously in accordance with regulatory requirements according to a 2014 study.
Of the one million kangaroos inspected by Federal Government veterinarians in 2014, only 25 were reported as not having been shot in the head. CLAIM 9: The national Code of Practice requires shooters to shoot at-foot joeys and decapitate or “crush the skull and destroy the brain” of pouch young. TRUE: To address concerns about the welfare of joeys, the KIAA introduced a male-only policy in 2013. Although blunt trauma to the head may be seen as cruel and violent by observers and may be unpleasant to perform from the animal’s perspective, the duration and extent of suffering is much less than other methods. The duration of distress prior to the use of blunt trauma is also likely to be less compared with other methods (such as overdose with barbiturate).
The Code of Practice is currently being reviewed through a project led by Agrifutures Australia. The review is being informed through a reference group of representatives from the Australian Veterinary Association, the RSPCA, industry and relevant government agencies.
CLAIM 10: Research confirms most dependent at-foot joeys are left in the field to suffer exposure, starvation, or predation, and that pouch joeys’ heads are generally swung against vehicles.
TRUE: To address concerns about the welfare of joeys, the KIAA introduced a male-only policy in 2013. Of the 24 youngat-foot that were observed in a 2014 study by Agrifutures Australia in 2014, only one was euthanised with a shot to the head. The reasons for harvesters not killing atfoot joeys despite the requirement in the Code of Practice include:
• Young often forage some distance from the mother and can be difficult to see.
• They tend to flee when their mother has been shot and are difficult to catch.
• If there are a number of young in the vicinity, it is difficult to know which one belongs to the mother.
• Some harvesters don’t like using blunt
trauma on the larger joeys but consider shooting at close range to be too dangerous. • Some joeys are deemed large enough
to survive on their own. Large pouch young were killed by a single forceful blow to the head, which included a large rock, heavy object or vehicle. This is in accordance with the Code of Practice.
CLAIM 11: Joeys killed or left to die are not recorded. Around 8 million dependent joeys are estimated to have died due to commercial shooting in the period 2000–2009. More than 110 000 joeys died from commercial shooting alone in 2015 based on reported figures.
PARTLY TRUE: The number of joeys killed are not recorded, therefore, the above estimates cannot be based in fact. However, since the KIAA introduced its male-only policy in 2013, less than 5 per cent of the kangaroos it harvests have been female. This has significantly reduced the number of joeys killed.
CLAIM 12: 75 per cent of emerging human pathogens originate in wildlife. Kangaroo is a wild bushmeat sold in supermarkets and restaurants. It is not tested for the many human-harming pathogens it harbours. FALSE: Kangaroo carcasses are all subject to an independent post mortem inspection by Department of Agriculture and Water Resources officials called Food Safety Meat Assessors or a third-party meat inspector under the supervision of a departmental veterinarian prior to being passed fit for human consumption.
All registered export establishments are required to participate in the National Carcase Microbiology Monitoring Program, which involves testing conducted by NATA accredited laboratories, under the Export Control (Wild Game Meat and Wild Game Meat Products) Orders 2010 and Amendment Orders 2014. In addition to the microbiological sampling, Meat Hygiene Assessments and Process monitoring is conducted. Cooking meat also destroys bacteria such as salmonella, camplyobacter and E. coli. It is recommended that kangaroo meat, like most meats, be cooked before eating. CLAIM 13: Wild kangaroos are shot and butchered in the field without supervision. They are transported on unrefrigerated open trucks exposed to dust and flies and frequently high ambient temperatures. PARTLY TRUE: To ensure wild game carcasses and wild game meat are wholesome, operators need to maintain appropriate hygiene. Field processors must ensure that their vehicles and equipment:
• are cleaned and sanitised whenever necessary to prevent contamination of wild game meat and wild game meat products;
• are clean before operations begin each day, and are cleaned at the end of operations each day; and
• if there is more than one shift in a day, are dry cleaned at the end of each shift are kept in a good state of repair. The Kangaroo Industries Association of Australia complies with all health and safety regulations. Game meat harvester vehicles are routinely checked by the Food Authority for compliance with requirements.
CLAIM 14: There have been repeated findings of contaminated kangaroo meat over many years. In 2014 Russia banned kangaroo meat imports for a third time due to pathogenic contamination. Acetic acid is routinely used to cleanse the meat of systemic contamination.
FALSE: Globally, there has never been a documented case of illness due to E. coli or salmonella from the consumption of kangaroo meat. In 2014, Russia banned the import of meat, fish and dairy from the EU, US, Australia, Canada and Norway in response to international sanctions. Kangaroo exports were affected by this ban. Food Standards Australian New Zealand allows the use of processing aids such as acetic acid and they are widely used in Australia. No processing aids are used for EU markets.