Mac Format

What is re-balling and does it work?

-

I’m near the point of throwing my 2009 MacBook Pro off the end of Blackpool Pier. It started having screen glitches and random ‘lock-ups’, which apparently are the symptoms of the Nvidia graphics fault. I also found it would refuse to boot up fully (the progress bar would get about a quarter way across, pause, and then reboot continuall­y). Apple quoted me £450 to have a new logic board fitted, so instead I went to an independen­t repairer to have the graphics processor re-balled. I have spent £89 on a ‘re-balling’ repair plus another £45 to have a new graphics processor fitted. After the first repair the graphics seemed OK, but the rebooting problem still occurred randomly. That’s when it went back for a new Nvidia processor to be fitted. For about two weeks it behaved flawlessly until on a cold day I got it out of the boot of my car and took it with me to a coffee shop. Yes, you guessed it, it just continuall­y rebooted making it completely unusable! I don’t suspect Yosemite, because it still exhibits this fault when trying to boot from an external HDD loaded with Mavericks. Mike O'Dea

Re-balling involves desolderin­g a chip from the circuit board and applying a new grid of tiny solder balls to the underside to reattach all the pins. Theoretica­lly it can fix problems with dry solder joints, but in practice it’s not something I recommend. Screen glitches and random crashes could indicate a fault with the graphics chip, but there could equally be a fault with one of the other chips on the motherboar­d, or one of the etched tracks on the circuit board itself. Also the re-balling process involves applying a lot of heat to the whole motherboar­d, which stresses chips and can cause other connection­s to fail.

Now that you are £134 in, it might be tempting to persevere with other repair options, or even pay the £450 for a new motherboar­d. My advice though, is to eBay the MacBook Pro “for parts or not working”. You should get at least £100 for it and you can put that towards a new laptop. Five or six years is a respectabl­e lifespan for a laptop and there comes a point where you are just throwing good money after bad.

 ??  ?? Repairs involving the logic board are very expensive and there’s no guarantee they’ll work.
Repairs involving the logic board are very expensive and there’s no guarantee they’ll work.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Australia