Pink resurfaces with a gloomy new CD
Weekend, October 13-15, 2017 Usually an icon of strength, singer sounds defeated Music
Things are not as perfect as they might seem in the land of Pink. The three-time Grammy winner may have loads of money, two kids and an 11-year marriage, but her new album is filled with unease and regret.
“Freeze frame, pause, rewind, stop,” she sings on Beautiful Trauma, a 13-track CD that taps into what could be called soccer mom angst. Success hasn’t made Pink happier: “Now I’m here and all I wanna do/ Is go back to playing Barbies in my room.”
It’s a carefully curated, slick album of bitter songs from a singer returning to pop after five years away. She’s usually an icon of empowerment and strength, but here seems defeated. Among the missteps is a duet with Eminem that sounds like it was rejected five years ago when the pair last collaborated and the dance song Secrets that makes Pink sound like Kylie Minogue, only more vapid.
Pink is 38 now and the music landscape has changed. Bad love is Pink’s thing now, even though Lorde and Halsey seem to have the corner on confessional pop.
Pink’s voice is better than ever, and she’s leaned on A-list producers — including Greg Kurstin, Max Martin and Jack Antonoff — but this is basically a breakup album from a woman in a committed relationship. If there’s any social commentary it is too muted.
Many songs seem as if she just woke up and realized the guy next to her is a total creep. Yet the liner notes thanks husband Carey Hart as “my muse and my love” and “You are the rock that we cling to.”
In Whatever You Want she warns “I feel like our ship’s going down tonight.” The title song has her calling her lover “perfect rock bottom” and “the nightmare I wake in.” Another song has her singing: “We had a thing but we lost it.”
Beautiful Trauma has plenty of swelling strings and a choir, slow piano moments meant to be meaningful, occasional swearing to keep it real for the kids and utter musical bombast, almost venturing into Meat Loaf’s operatic self-indulgence.
By the end, Pink utterly tips into parody with the overwrought Wild Hearts Can’t Be Broken and the tiresome torch song You Get My Love. This CD might be about trauma, but it’s not always beautiful.
Pink’s voice is better than ever, and she’s leaned on A-list producers ... but this is basically a breakup album from a woman in a committed relationship.
Following a five-year break from pop, Pink is back with Beautiful Trauma.