Pa­trick Brown speaks out Ex-PC leader vows he will clear name

Wit­nesses con­tra­dict key al­le­ga­tions from Brown ac­cusers

Ottawa Sun - - ADVERTISING FEATURE - JAMES WAL­LACE and ANTONELLA ARTUSO

Key as­pects of a CTV News story that made damn­ing sex­ual mis­con­duct al­le­ga­tions against for­mer On­tario PC leader Pa­trick Brown ap­pear to be un­rav­el­ling.

Brown re­signed as party leader in late Jan­uary af­ter the news broad­caster pub­lished claims that Brown tried to pres­sure two young women, one a high school stu­dent and the other an in­tern in his of­fice, into un­wanted sex.

CTV ac­knowl­edged Tues­day night a piv­otal ac­cu­sa­tion — that Brown plied an un­der­age high school girl with booze — is not true.

The ac­cuser was nei­ther in high school nor un­der­age, she now ad­mits.

A Post­media ex­clu­sive re­vealed Satur­day that at the time the woman was in high school, Brown did not have an up­stairs bed­room as she claimed.

Now, Post­media has in­ter­viewed peo­ple con­nected to Brown and the two women mak­ing al­le­ga­tions against Brown, and dis­pute key claims made against him.

CTV said in a Tues­day story that “the first ac­cuser main­tains the in­ci­dent hap­pened dur­ing a visit to Brown’s home with a mu­tual friend,” adding that “that friend told CTV News he has no rec­ol­lec­tion of the night.”

How­ever, when con­tacted by Post­media, the friend in­sisted he wasn’t with her that night or with her ever at Brown’s home.

“I have known (her) since I was 16,” said the friend, who didn’t want to be iden­ti­fied be­cause of the vir­u­lent con­tro­versy sur­round­ing the story.

“I was ac­tu­ally very good friends with her,” he said. “We met through church at a youth group there.”

The friend said he was con­tacted by CTV Tues­day af­ter­noon, and told the woman claimed she had been “par­ty­ing” with him and an­other friend on the night Brown pressed her for sex, an al­le­ga­tion he adamantly de­nied.

“I don’t know if he sug­gested I had been drink­ing but I would dis­pute any al­le­ga­tion I was drink­ing at the time,” the friend told Post­media. “Quite sim­ply I didn’t start drink­ing un­til a lit­tle bit later in life.”

The friend, who Brown de­scribes as an “ac­quain­tance,” said it’s true he told CTV he had “no rec­ol­lec­tion” but also made it clear that if the events the ac­cuser de­scribed hap­pened, he was never there and had no knowl­edge of them.

Nor has he ever seen Brown or the young woman to­gether.

“I have no rec­ol­lec­tion of her in­ter­act­ing with Pa­trick at a bar or else­where,” he said.

The first ac­cuser is­sued a state­ment through her lawyer, David Butt, in which the woman said she sticks by her story.

‘Ex­posed to abuse’

“The rea­son I will not en­gage in any more pub­lic dis­cus­sion is that go­ing pub­lic with this in­ci­dent has ex­posed me to abuse on so­cial me­dia that no hu­man be­ing de­serves,” she said.

Brown’s sec­ond ac­cuser, who worked as a sum­mer stu­dent in his of­fice in 2013, said he fed her drinks fol­low­ing a Barrie hockey fundraiser, kissed her with­out her per­mis­sion and tried to pres­sure her into sex in his bed­room dur­ing a party, which she de­scribed to CTV as a “sex­ual as­sault.”

“The next thing I know he’s kiss­ing me,” she told CTV. “He con­tin­ued to kiss me and he laid me down on the bed and got on top of me,” she said.

“I could feel his erec­tion on my legs when he was on top of me so I felt that it would have gone to sex­ual in­ter­course if I had not done any­thing,” she said. “I would char­ac­ter­ize that as a sex­ual as­sault.”

A woman who knows the sec­ond ac­cuser told Post­media that she ad­mit­ted at the time that the “en­counter with Pa­trick (had been) just a kiss, noth­ing more.”

But the day af­ter that al­leged as­sault, the staffer con­fided to her friend that “there was just a kiss, noth­ing more.

“She did not in­ti­mate to me that it was in­ap­pro­pri­ate or un­wanted in na­ture at all and she also ex­pressed re­grets that she had been un­faith­ful to her boyfriend at that time.”

“I asked her if it was go­ing to be awk­ward with Pa­trick Brown and she said no.”

Brown has main­tained the for­mer staffer, who has ad­mit­ted she was drunk at the time, in fact kissed him.

Other sources at Brown’s home that night, who had gath­ered there fol­low­ing a char­ity hockey game in Barrie pre­vi­ously told Post­media that the young woman had been fol­low­ing him around at the party.

Mikaela Pat­ter­son, who was dat­ing Brown at the time, was in the next room in fact.

Pat­ter­son said she and a girl­friend no­ticed the young woman fol­low­ing Brown around at the party.

“We went back to his house and the girl was kind of fol­low­ing him around, which an­noyed me,” she said. “And then Pa­trick ended up driv­ing her home ... and he spent the rest of the evening with me and Katie, my girl­friend.”

The for­mer staffer also told CTV that she re­ceived a raise fol­low­ing the in­ci­dent, which is sug­ges­tive of a pay­off.

Look­ing for raise

How­ever, sources with knowl­edge of Brown’s Barrie op­er­a­tion said in fact it was the for­mer staffer who came look­ing for a raise, af­ter learn­ing a new crop of in­terns were be­ing paid as much as she was mak­ing, de­spite hav­ing worked in Brown’s of­fice for longer. On that ba­sis, she asked for, and was given a raise.

Brown, in an ex­clu­sive in­ter­view with Post­media last Fri­day, called the al­le­ga­tions against him “ab­so­lute lies” that have dev­as­tated both his ca­reer and per­sonal life. He said the “truth will come out” and that he’s con­tem­plat­ing le­gal ac­tion to de­fend his rep­u­ta­tion.

“CTV News fab­ri­cated a ma­li­cious and false re­port about me from two anony­mous ac­cusers,” Brown said in a Face­book post. “Af­ter a long three weeks, CTV News has now ad­mit­ted that it got it wrong.”

In an in­ter­view with Global TV that aired Wed­nes­day, Brown said of the sec­ond ac­cuser: “I want to know who put her up to this.”

CTV has said it stands by its story, call­ing Brown’s pub­lic con­cerns about their story as “ground­less and wrong.”

Brown’s first ac­cuser, through CTV, also said she’s stand­ing by her story. The sec­ond ac­cuser told Post­media she’s do­ing the same.

I have no rec­ol­lec­tion of her in­ter­act­ing with Pa­trick at a bar or else­where.” Mu­tual friend of Pa­trick Brown and an ac­cuser

Pa­trick Brown, for­mer On­tario PC leader, says the al­le­ga­tions of sex­ual mis­con­duct have dev­as­tated his ca­reer and per­sonal life.

CRAIG ROBERT­SON

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada

© PressReader. All rights reserved.