What­ever trial verdict, pub­lic has own views

Simcoe Reformer - - OPINION -

With on­tario court Judge tim­o­thy Lip­son rul­ing thurs­day that the trial of two se­nior po­lit­i­cal aides to for­mer on­tario pre­mier dal­ton mcguinty in con­nec­tion with the gas plants scan­dal will con­tinue, some per­spec­tive is in or­der.

Whether david Liv­ingston and Laura miller are guilty on the re­main­ing charges they face of at­tempt­ing to com­mit mis­chief (which Lip­son down­graded from mis­chief ) and il­le­gal use of a com­puter, re­gard­ing the de­struc­tion of gov­ern­ment doc­u­ments, is the judge’s de­ci­sion.

the crown pre­vi­ously with­drew the most se­ri­ous charge, breach of trust, say­ing there was no rea­son­able prospect of con­vic­tion.

Lip­son re­jected a de­fence mo­tion call­ing for a di­rected verdict on the re­main­ing charges — sim­i­lar to what hap­pened in the Sud­bury by-elec­tion bribery trial. in that case, the de­fence mo­tion was suc­cess­ful.

in this case, Lip­son said there’s enough ev­i­dence to sug­gest it’s pos­si­ble the de­fen­dants are guilty of the charges.

this doesn’t mean Liv­ingston and miller will au­to­mat­i­cally be con­victed, just that the case against them can pro­ceed.

That said, on­tar­i­ans have a right to ex­pect a higher stan­dard of con­duct from their gov­ern­ment than that se­nior on­tario Lib­er­als are not con­victed of break­ing the law.

The stan­dard of proof in these tri­als, where the lib­erty of the ac­cused is at stake, is “proof be­yond a rea­son­able doubt.” it is rightly set high to pro­tect the in­no­cent.

But it in no way, in­clud­ing in the ab­sence of con­vic­tions, pre­vents any­one from hav­ing and ex­press­ing an opin­ion about how our Lib­eral gov­ern­ment be­haved in both these cases.

In our view, the ac­tions of on­tario’s Lib­eral gov­ern­ment over two ad­min­is­tra­tions per­tain­ing to the gas plants and Sud­bury by-elec­tion con­tro­ver­sies were ap­palling.

They were the an­tithe­sis of ev­ery prom­ise the Lib­er­als made in their 14 years in power to run an open and trans­par­ent gov­ern­ment, and to spend our money wisely and ju­di­ciously.

The guilt or in­no­cence of the ac­cused is up to the courts.

Whether what the Lib­er­als did was wrong is up to the pub­lic to de­cide, and the vot­ers will get to de­liver their verdict in the June elec­tion.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada

© PressReader. All rights reserved.