United Church court hear­ing on de­frock­ing athe­ist min­is­ter de­layed

Truro Daily News - - Canada - TORONTO


An un­prece­dented ec­cle­si­as­ti­cal court hear­ing that could see the United Church de­frock a self­pro­fessed athe­ist min­is­ter who does not be­lieve in the Bi­ble has been post­poned in­def­i­nitely.

The hear­ing on whether Gretta Vosper is suit­able for the min­istry — sched­uled months ago — was to have taken place this month.

How­ever, Vosper, who is the min­is­ter at West Hill United Church in Toronto’s east end, re­cently re­ceived a letter in­form­ing her of the de­lay.

“It is now clear that the panel will not be estab­lished in time to hold the hear­ing on the dates that you are hold­ing in Novem­ber 2017,” ac­cord­ing to the church letter sent to her.

Act­ing on com­plaints about Vosper, a United Church re­view­ing panel in Septem­ber last year rec­om­mended in a split de­ci­sion that Vosper be de­frocked for her be­liefs. The hear­ing sched­uled for this month was to make a fi­nal church de­ci­sion on her fate.

Vosper, 59, who has been fight­ing to keep her job as a min­is­ter, said the church of­fered no rea­son in its letter for the de­lay, nor did it in­di­cate when the hear­ing be­fore a ju­di­cial com­mit­tee might now take place. A church spokes­woman sug­gested the is­sue was, in part, lo­gis­ti­cal.

“I un­der­stand the ju­di­cial com­mit­tee ex­ec­u­tive has not fi­nal­ized dates for the hear­ing,” Mary-Frances De­nis said this week. “The par­ties are still work­ing on a num­ber of pre­lim­i­nary mat­ters that need to be ad­dressed, in­clud­ing find­ing dates that would ac­com­mo­date ev­ery­one’s sched­ules.”

Vosper, how­ever, won­dered whether the prob­lem runs deeper than a sched­ul­ing is­sue.

Un­der laws gov­ern­ing the church’s court sys­tem, she said, a hear­ing is sup­posed to mir­ror the civil courts in pro­vid­ing an im­par­tial fo­rum. Given the charged na­ture of the pro­ceed­ings against her, Vosper ques­tioned whether that would be pos­si­ble.

“I do think that it will be a chal­lenge for them to put to­gether an un­bi­ased com­mit­tee as they are re­quired to do in or­der to meet the stan­dard set by the civil courts,” Vosper said. “Even if they were to find a United Church mem­ber who had never heard of me, as soon as the is­sues were shared, the in­di­vid­ual would very likely have a strong opin­ion.”

The min­is­ter, who was or­dained in 1993 and joined her West Hill con­gre­ga­tion in 1997, has been up­front about her be­liefs for years. Most of her cur­rent con­gre­gants are sup­port­ive of her views but some church mem­bers have been crit­i­cal, say­ing her be­liefs are at fun­da­men­tal odds with United Church doc­trine and values.

The Toronto Con­fer­ence in­ter­view com­mit­tee, which con­ducted the re­view on Vosper, deemed her un­suit­able to con­tinue in or­dained min­istry be­cause “she does not be­lieve in God, Je­sus Christ or the Holy Spirit.” How­ever, a four-per­son mi­nor­ity on the 23-mem­ber com­mit­tee dis­agreed, say­ing the church had al­ways adapted to meet the spir­i­tual needs of its mem­bers and that Vosper’s un­ortho­dox views were shared by oth­ers.

While the saga un­folds, Vosper said she and other West Hill mem­bers have been trav­el­ling across Canada to talk to other United Church mem­bers and ad­her­ents. The re­sponse, she said, has been wel­com­ing.

“Each has been rich and re­ward­ing for all who have par­tic­i­pated, and has al­lowed West Hill’s peo­ple to share their per­spec­tive about what it is we do,” Vosper said. “That has been very good.”


Rev. Gretta Vosper is seen at West Hill United Church in Toronto.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada

© PressReader. All rights reserved.