Historians fault Japan on ‘comfort women’ flak
Some American historians are urging their Japanese counterparts not to allow the Japanese government to minimize the prevalence of “comfort women” during World War II.
To mark the 70th anniversary of war’s end, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is now “pushing to put a gloss on Japan’s wartime history and, in turn, to loosen some of the postwar constraints on its military”, said a report in The Washington Post on Tuesday.
A public letter was signed by 19 academics from Princeton, Columbia, American University and elsewhere to be published in the March issue of Perspectives on History, a magazine of the American Historical Association.
“We stand with the many historians in Japan and elsewhere who have worked to bring to light the facts about this and other atrocities of World War II,” the letter said, referring to the women who were forced into providing sexual favors to the Japanese Imperial Army in wartime.
The American historians express their dismay “at recent attempts by the Japanese government to suppress statements in history textbooks both in Japan and elsewhere”, according to the letter.
An estimated 30,000 to 200,000 women from China, Korea and other Asian countries were forced to be sex slaves in the 1930s and 1940s. Chinese researchers’ findings indicate the number is about 400,000, according to Peipei Qiu, professor of Chinese and Japanese and director of the Asian Studies Program at Vassar College, New York.
The issue is controversial in Asia, especially when the Japanese government recently offered a different interpretation and attempted to “get the American publishing house McGraw Hill to remove two paragraphs about comfort women from a college textbook”, according to the Post.
The book, Traditions and Encounters: A Global Perspective on the Past, said the Japanese Army “forcibly recruited, conscripted and dragooned as many as 200,000 women aged 14 to 20 to serve in military brothels, called ‘comfort houses’ ”. It also says that the Japanese military “massacred large numbers of comfort women to cover up the operation”.
The dispute lingers on the number of the women coerced into sexual slavery and the precise role that Japanese troops played in their procurement during the war. Many Japanese conservatives regarded the women simply as prostitutes.
McGraw Hill declined the request, saying that “scholars are aligned behind the historical fact of comfort women” and that it “unequivocally” stands behind the book.
Herbert Ziegler, an associate professor at the University of Hawaii and co-author of the textbook, said that he got an e-mail late last year from an official of the Japanese Consulate General in Hawaii.
The Japanese side requested a discussion about the passages, which Ziegler called “an infringement of my freedom of speech and my academic freedom”.
She co-authored a book called Chinese Comfort Women: Testimonies from Imperial Japan's Sex Slaves, with Su Zhiliang and Chen Lifei, two scholars based in Shanghai, China.
The book, which is the first English-language account of the women’s ordeal, features personal narratives of 12 victims and was published last year by the Oxford University Press as part of the Oxford Oral History Series.
Qiu said in her book launch at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies that if the wounded failed to be recognized by history, it would be a new wound for them.
“Human sufferings of such magnitude cannot, and should not, be dismissed,” she said.
Pedro Chan, an adviser to the Pacific Aviation Museum, Pearl Harbor, Hawaii; the Chinese American Museum of Los Angeles; and the Flying Tigers Historical Organization in the US, collected photos of the women and supported a World War II memorial statue in California last year.