Lessons of a classroom test
Bohunt School, deep in rural Hampshire, was pretty much unknown in China before last August. It shot to fame thanks to the BBC series Are Our Kids Tough Enough? Chinese School, which generated a debate in Britain and China about contrasts in the countries’ teaching methods.
Now its head teacher, Neil Strowger, is invited to conferences in China, while its students have had to get used to Chinese visitors peeking through their classroom windows. Some even greet the visitors with nihao (hello in Chinese) and a friendly smile.
Despite its large appeal, Strowger said the BBC series was a sitcom more than a serious documentary, arguing that it “was produced as entertainment rather than educational research”.
“The editing painted a very simplistic storyline: hardworking Chinese teachers battle poor behavior to ensure success in tests versus English teachers who are very student-centered but are ‘too nice’ and so lose,” he said.
In the three-part program, five Chinese teachers taught 50 students at Bohunt School for four weeks. The finale ended with tests in which the students studying the Chinese method achieved marks about 10 percent higher in math and science compared with the rest of their year group, who were taught by their regular teachers in the English manner.
Strowger said genuine educational exchanges did occur between the Chinese and English teachers during filming but were deleted in the editing. Teachers often observed each other’s lessons, he said.
Philip Avery, director of learning and strategy for Bohunt Trust, which operates the school, said: “They (the Chinese educators) would regularly come and talk to our teachers about, ‘I am really struggling with these students, what can you suggest?’ So there was an awful lot of collaboration.”
As a result of the exchanges, teachers at Bohunt have adopted a wider range of methods, including those used widely in China, for example readjusting the structure of its science department.
According to Avery, what the school had before the program is that it had heads of science for different age groups. Biology, chemistry and physics were grouped under Science. Now they have heads for each of these subjects, because after the program, the faculty realize that each subject has its unique features and calls for different teaching methods, rather than the inquiry method that was used widely in all these subjects.
Apart from the final examinations in the program, which the BBC presented as a competition, the school has continued to track the progress of those students who took part.
The findings suggest better progress was made in biology under the Chinese method of teaching, while chemistry and physics were better in the traditional Bohunt style. Math was fairly even, with students on both sides feeling happier with the different methods.
Like most schools in Britain, Bohunt uses the inquiry method, where the onus is on the student to acquire information by asking questions.
“That works really well in chemistry and physics where they can do calculations and can run experiments,” Avery said. “Biology, less so, as the students weren’t going to understand anything from dissecting that they would have from a diagram.”
The Chinese approach on the show was for teachers to take control of lessons and explain more in a focused way, which gets the information across quicker, he said. This gave the students more time to practice and go over things again when needed.
The collaboration went both ways, too. The Chinese teachers went away with wider strategies, while Bohunt took on board things such as the importance of “teacher talk” in lessons.
“We would previously have been rather nervous about seeing too much teacher talk in classrooms, and I think that’s changed,” Strowger said. “Our new learning and teaching policy said that in certain circumstances, rote learning and teacher talk, a more didactic approach, is absolutely fine.”
Juan Cole, the school’s head of Chinese, added: “It was a really interesting experiment for us to see what works and what does not. Certain methods worked for certain students, and one of our teachers has started adjusting parts of the curriculum.”
The students were divided on which methods they preferred.
Philippa Murray, 15, was one of the young people who appeared in the BBC program. She said she found the Chinese teaching style enjoyable, especially when the class work became more challenging.
Of the Chinese math lessons, she said: “The way the teacher explained it was very detailed. For some people, they might have lost interest, but I was fine with it and very happy to keep listening to what the teacher was saying.”
The year 10 student said the experiment affected how she sees education. “When I think back to the Chinese school, I appreciate how that taught me to treat myself better because I am quite hard on myself when it comes to learning and when I do not get something right. I have learned how to deal with it now after being in that environment.”
Scarlett Stevens, also 15, was less fond of the Chinese methods, especially the classroom competitiveness. “The Chinese style was much more like a typical English college or university, like lectures and notetaking, which is much more common for a subject that you have chosen yourself, a single subject, whereas it was quite difficult doing that for five different subjects, just the same thing over and over again.”
She said she prefers the English way of discovery learning and finding out things for yourself rather than being told what the right answer is or what the right formula is.
The Bohunt experiment came after Shanghai students had consistently ranked top for math in the Program for International Student Assessment, which is issued by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. By comparison, British students at the time ranked 26th.
The PISA ranking triggered global interest in Chinese methods and supplementary materials. Britain increased exchanges with Chinese teachers and schools to find out what can improve the quality of its schools.
Over the past 18 months, 127 math teachers from Shanghai have shared their experiences and skills in English primary schools. British educators say their techniques, such as spending more time on subjects and teacher-led explanation, have already had a positive effect.
“Most people are surprised at the way Shanghai … performed on PISA because they thought, with rote teaching, it seemed likely that the students were to fare worse than others on tasks that require an application of knowledge and a problem-solving ability,” said David Johnson, reader in comparative and international education at the University of Oxford.
That is a misunderstanding, he said. “It is not possible to solve problems and do inquiry learning without the necessary subject bases. Often things like inquiry-based learning are not always, across different countries, in the domain of the school, so many systems don’t feel the need to make that a strong part of the curriculum.”
China, which concentrates on establishing the basics, understands much better that young people are exposed to a number of opportunities both inside and outside school to think mathematically or to solve real-life problems in other ways, he added.
“So how one balances out the twin demands of a good, strong knowledge base and sufficient opportunities to apply these to real-life problems is the important mixture.”
Tim Ayres, head of biology at Bohunt School, is thinking hard about a good mix of different teaching methods.
“Nobody is going to change the world by being told stuff. They are going to change the world by developing ideas. That said, if you look at the earlier years there’s a huge emphasis on inquiry and practical (studies), teaching them (students) the skills and getting them engaged in science.
“As you move toward the final result, it does step up that lecture style and it also prepares them for A-levels, which will be a bit more lecture-style.”
Li Wensha Wang Mingjie
It seems the BBC program has not only brought fame to Bohunt, but also business opportunities.
The school’s trust has signed a deal with Wenzhou Xinzhi Education Co to set up Wenzhou Bohunt International School, which is due to open in 2018 and teach a Bohunt-style curriculum as well as offer GCSE and A-level examinations.
It will be the first time a state school in Britain has opened a private school in China. More than 40 British private schools have established campuses in Asia and the Middle East, as demand for a British-style education continues to rise. The exchanges between Bohunt and China also benefit its 1,500 students, a quarter of whom are now learning Mandarin.
“The students are incredibly excited about Chinese culture, the history and traditions, but also in the youth culture,” Avery said. “It is very difficult to bring across in rural Hampshire, which is not at all racially diverse. The exchange is fantastic.”
Contact the writers through firstname.lastname@example.org
Top: Students in the grounds of Bohunt School. Above: Science, technology, engineering and Math lessons in the school allow students to apply their scientific and math knowledge in the real world, often with local industry partners. Right: A student in the school practices Chinese calligraphy. Mandarin is taught to more than 400 learners, with many taught using an immersion method.