Turkey tries anti Erdogan journalists on ‘terror’ charges
Case intensifies alarm over press freedom in Turkey
Staff from one of Turkey’s most respected opposition newspapers yesterday rejected as absurd “terror” charges against them on the first day of a trial which has intensified alarm over press freedom under President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. The 17 defendants from the Cumhuriyet daily were detained from October last year and a dozen of them have now spent more than eight months in jail without being convicted of any crime.
They have been held under a state of emergency imposed after the July 2016 failed coup aimed at ousting Erdogan that the authorities blame on US-based preacher Fethullah Gulen. The staff-including writers, cartoonists and executives-were applauded by supporters crammed into the Istanbul courtroom as the trial opened, an AFP journalist said. Supporters released dozens of multicolored balloons outside the courthouse, chanting: “Don’t be silenced! A free media is a right!”
If convicted, the defendants face varying terms of up to 43 years in jail. In an extraordinary coincidence, the trial opened on Turkey’s annual national day of the press which marks the end of official censorship in the Ottoman Empire in 1908 under Sultan Abdulhamid II.
Those appearing in court included some of the best known names in Turkish journalism including the columnist Kadri Gursel, the paper’s editor-in-chief Murat Sabuncu, cartoonist Musa Kart as well as its chairman Akin Atalay. They are charged with supporting in the newspaper’s writings three groups considered by Turkey as terror outfits-the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), the ultra-left Revolutionary People’s Liberation Party-Front (DHKP-C) and Gulen’s movement, which Ankara calls the Fethullah Terror Organization (FETO).
The indictment accuses Cumhuriyet of beginning a “perception operation” with the aim of starting an “asymmetric war” against Erdogan. But supporters insist the paper has always been bitterly critical of the three groups, including Gulen’s organization. Gulen denies any link to the failed coup. “To say I was in contact with FETO members is illogical and against good sense,” Gursel told the court. “There is nothing to justify my jailing-nothing apart from slander,” he added. Atalay said it was the authorities who were scared. “But Cumhuriyet will not give in... independence and liberty are written into the DNA of the paper.”
‘Test for Turkey’
Cumhuriyet (Republic), which was set up in 1924 and is Turkey’s oldest mainstream national title, has been a thorn in the side of Erdogan in recent years. It is one of the few genuine opposition voices in the press, which is dominated by strongly pro-government media and bigger mainstream dailies that are increasingly wary of challenging the authorities. Also being tried in the case is the investigative journalist Ahmet Sik who in 2011 wrote an explosive book “The Imam’s Army” exposing the grip Gulen’s movement had on the Turkish state. Eleven of the 17 including Gursel, Sabuncu, Kart and Sik, are held in custody, while the others are free. Since their arrests, Cumhuriyet has continued publishing the columns of the jailed journalists but with a blank white space instead of text.
“This trial is a test for Turkey,” Aydin Engin, one of the writers on trial who was freed after his initial arrest. “Erdogan says justice is balanced in Turkey. Now we will see.” Being tried in absentia is the paper’s former editor-inchief Can Dundar, who was last year sentenced to five years and 10 months in jail over a front-page story accusing the government of sending weapons to Syria. He has now fled Turkey for Germany.
‘Journalism on trial’
The opposition fears the emergency has been used to go after anyone who dares defy the government and the trial is seen as a test for press freedom under Erdogan. Turkey ranks 155th on the latest Reporters Without Borders (RSF) world press freedom index, below Belarus and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
According to the P24 press freedom group, there are 166 journalists behind bars in Turkey, most of whom were arrested under the state of emergency. Erdogan, however, insisted in an interview earlier this month there were just “two real journalists” behind bars in Turkey and anyone else was jailed for offences including robbing ATMs. “It’s journalism in Turkey, not just Cumhuriyet, that is being put on trial,” said RSF secretary general Christophe Deloire.
The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, in an opinion released last month, said it found that the detention of the staff was arbitrary and that they should be immediately released and given the right to compensation. Filiz Kerestecioglu, an MP from the opposition Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP), commented: “According to the government, all of the opposition are terrorists. The only ones that are not terrorists are themselves.”
ISTANBUL: A journalist holds a banner yesterday outside the headquarters of opposition daily newspaper Cumhuriyet.