Time for visionary leaders in Lesotho
Almost a month after the release of the report of a southern African Development Community (SADC) inquiry into political instability in lesotho, many citizens remain in the dark over both its contents and their implications for the future.
led by Justice mpaphi Phumaphi of the Botswana High Court, the 10-strong commission was established after a SADC leaders’ meeting last July.
Following months of political and legal and wrangling, its report was finally presented to lesotho’s National Assembly and senate on February 8 and 10 respectively.
the leaders set up the inquiry after the killing last June 25 of former lesotho Defence Force (LDF) commander maaparankoe mahao, by soldiers sent to arrest him for an alleged mutiny plot. the killing occurred after mahao had been replaced as commander by lieutenant-general tlali Kamoli.
the commission was mandated, among others, to review investigations into the alleged mutiny plot by elements of the LDF, and mahao’s role in it, to investigate the circumstances surrounding his killing, and to identify wrongdoing with a view to bringing perpetrators to justice.
mahao was appointed by former Prime minister thomas thabane in 2014 and dismissed by incoming Prime minister Pakalitha mosisili in 2015; while Kamoli was dismissed by thabane in 2014 and reappointed by mosisili in 2015.
the commission was mandated to investigate the legality or otherwise of these changes to LDF leadership, and to examine the effect of Kamoli’s reappointment on the unity and coherence of the LDF.
the Phumaphi Commission’s report was meant for release in November 2015, but LDF special Forces Commander tefo Hashatsi launched a court case to annul the commis- sion. A legal and political tussle between the lesotho government and the SADC followed, with the government arguing that it could not receive the report because the legitimacy of the commission was being considered by domestic courts. But SADC resolved that it could not be bound by a ruling of the lesotho High Court in the matter; and the case was subsequently dismissed by the court.
meanwhile, mosisili was ostensibly persuaded to receive the report by his fellow southern African leaders at a summit in Botswana in January.
He then moved to table the report before lesotho’s legislature.
Phumaphi Findings What did Pumaphi find and recommend; and what action has been taken to move the country out of the paralysis of governance and public political tension of the past year?
Mutiny and Mahao’s Role the commission challenged the veracity of the allegations that the plot existed at all: it found that mutiny suspects were tortured to confess and implicate others, and that mahao’s connection to a plot was doubtful.
Killing of Mahao the commission found that mahao was subjected to persistent threats and attempts on his life, including on formal army occasions by senior soldiers. His arrest, and the arrests of others, were authorized by, or carried out with the full knowledge of Defence minister tšeliso mokhosi.
But the minister had exercised no oversight over the army’s action, nor had the army provided him feedback and updates. It was further found that mahao either did not resist arrest or did not offer resistance commensurate with the amount of force used to subdue and eventually kill him: he was confronted by no less than 10 heavily-armed soldiers and killed by three AK-47 bullets fired at close range. The commission cast doubt on the probability that he arrived in hospital both alive and able to walk.
Police Investigation into the killing of
Mahao the commission found that police investigations were hindered by Kamoli’s refusal to hand over suspects and by the withholding of material evidence. It found in general that the LDF had been defying the rule of law.
Political killings and kidnapping of sol
diers the commission found that evidence provided to courts during habeas corpus applications indicated that some serving LDF personnel had been abducted in contravention of LDF procedures. But it found no evidence for political killings, with only the death of businessman thabiso tšosane fuelling public perception of a political motivation.
Legality of appointments and dismissals the commission found that thabane’s ap- pointment of mahao as Commander and his dismissal of Kamoli were legal and proper. It also found that mosisili’s removal of mahao and reappointment of Kamoli were also legal but ill-advised.
Kamoli’s reappointment and its effects the commission found that Kamoli’s reappointment perpetuated divisions within LDF, and that the flight of opposition leaders who feared Kamoli was a reflection of the country’s instability.
OTHER findings the commission endorsed earlier reports which noted that mandate overlaps between police and the army caused conflict between the two institutions. It also found that the army and police were politicized, and identified the divergent political leanings of these institutions.
Recommendations Key among the recommendations of the commission were that: the police be allowed, facilitated and equipped to finish investigating Mahao’s killing without hindrance, and to bring suspects to justice; Government remove Kamoli from LDF command and suspend all soldiers suspected of crimes while investigations continue; Government initiate institutional and/ or constitutional reforms to eliminate the overlap of mandates within the security sector; Government grant amnesty to exiles and military detainees accused of mutiny; and SADC launch the oversight committee recommended by last July’s SADC leaders’ meeting.
...Continued on page 14