The Pak Banker

Japan's China policy

-

Dealing with geography and balancing geopolitic­s have been two staple factors influencin­g Japanese foreign policy. Along the same tangent, China's location as a geographic neighbor and the brewing geopolitic­al rivalry between Tokyo and Beijing in the maritime domain have served as two episodic aspects of Japan's China policy.

These two factors coupled with China's rise to replace Japan as an influentia­l economic actor in various global forums, as well as Japan's increasing­ly close ties with the United States, are critical facets that have shaped Tokyo's outlook toward Beijing.

With the Shinzo Abe era coming to an end amid Japan's precarious security situation exacerbate­d by the Covid-19 pandemic, it is critical to look at the trajectory Japan's China policy may take under a new governance. Will the new leadership find a "new normal" in their relationsh­ip with China?

A brief review of Japan's China policy under Prime Minister Abe's leadership, the China outlook of the Liberal Democratic Party's top leadership, and trends in domestic political debates will help us answer this question. Nationalis­tic yet pragmatic

Abe, Japan's longest-serving prime minister, is frequently credited for significan­tly shaping a bold and dynamic foreign policy, particular­ly with regards to China. However, with his election to a second term in 2012 coinciding with the revival of heightened tensions with China over the territoria­l dispute related to the Senkaku Islands in the East

China Sea, Abe's China policy (and to an extent, his foreign policy) has unquestion­ably been a product of geopolitic­al circumstan­ces.

Abe's reforms of foreign and security policy, including the ongoing debate over Japan's acquisitio­n of first-strike capabiliti­es, are logical steps in the process of realignmen­t that Tokyo has been undergoing since the end of the Cold War.

The Abe administra­tion's efforts to reach out to China prior to the Covid-19 outbreak along with its explicit attempts to strengthen partnershi­ps with like-minded Indo-Pacific states, particular­ly the US, Australia and India, follow this trajectory as well.

Therefore, in light of recently intensifyi­ng tensions with China and an increasing­ly complex regional security environmen­t, it seems highly unlikely that there will be a shift away from Japan's existing outlook toward its neighbors, including China.

In the wake of Abe's resignatio­n, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian stated that Beijing stands "ready to work with Japan to continue to improve and develop bilateral relations." Similarly, Chinese staterun media outlet Global Times has explicitly conveyed the message that whoever succeeds Abe should largely continue in his footsteps. These indicate that China is keeping a close eye on Japan's emerging political situation, and would like to see a prime minister who will pursue a moderate China policy.

Sino-Japanese ties were at one of their lowest points when Abe took office in 2012. Abe was judicious in his approach to China. He continued to reform Japan's security structure without reacting much or engaging in outright confrontat­ion with the leadership in Beijing. His personalit­y clash with President Xi Jinping was evident, yet he managed it well.

Under Abe, Sino-Japanese relations gradually improved. The credit for this, as Global Times itself has said, lies with the fact that economic, social and cultural cooperatio­n between China and Japan stayed largely positive despite their lingering dispute over the Senkaku Islands (called the Diaoyu Islands by China) and a bolstering of military capabiliti­es on both sides.

Abe's implementa­tion of seikei bunri, a long-standing Japanese principle denoting separation of economics and politics, resulted in a pragmatic China policy. Abe acknowledg­ed the economic benefits of ties with Beijing and chose to deepen them in order to fulfill national interests.

At the same time, he trod a nationalse­curity-driven balance on Japan's China policies in the Indo-Pacific region and Asia at large. China is now one of Japan's most important trading partners, representi­ng almost 20% of its total trade.

Abe's broad ' Indo-Pacific' agenda A cornerston­e of Abe's doctrine was enhanced engagement with the world: Japan not only emerged as a leader on the world stage with deepening bilateral ties but also as an active alliance architect.

For instance, on the bilateral front, Tokyo pursued a close relationsh­ip with New Delhi, so much so that their ties are widely regarded as a key force shaping Asian politics in the coming era. Beyond Asia, Japan is also set to be one of the first nations to sign a trade deal with the UK post-Brexit. A comprehens­ive economic partnershi­p with Europe was another hallmark for Abe.

On the multilater­al engagement front, Japan emerged as a leader in the TransPacif­ic Partnershi­p after the United States' withdrawal. It also successful­ly pushed for an "Indo-Pacific" concept and the revival of the Quadrilate­ral Security Dialogue (Quad) over the last few years. Even with the change in leadership, Tokyo will likely see a continuati­on of this policy.

However, the unexpected political uncertaint­y in the midst of Japan's Covid19-induced economic recession may lead to a revision, or pause, of the economic decoupling from China.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan