High sugar diet as damaging to the brain as extreme stress, experts warn
In light of mounting evidence indicating the link between a high sugar diet and ill health, it is now widely accepted that more should be done to encourage people to reduce their consumption of sugar. Many interest groups are pushing for the imposition of a “sin tax” on sweet drinks, and dietary guidelines in the US and UK have been tightened to reflect the changing scientific evidence.
The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends no more than 10 percent of a person’s daily energy should come from added sugars, or those found naturally in juices and honey, which equates to around 50g or 12 teaspoons a day.
And while the links between a high-sugar diet and obesity, with all its accompanying ills, are well documented, experts are now turning their attention to the other ways sugar can affect the body.
In a recent study, a team at the University of New South Wales concluded that sugar is as damaging to the brain as extreme stress or abuse. Research associate Jayanthi Maniam and professor of pharmacology Margaret Morris were involved in the study and discussed their findings with The Conversation:
“The changes we observed to the region of the brain that controls emotional behaviour and cognitive function were more extensive than those caused by extreme early life stress,” they revealed.
“It is known that adverse experiences early in life, such as extreme stress or abuse, increase the risk of poor mental health and psychiatric disorders later in life.
“The number of traumatic events – accidents; witnessing an injury; bereavement; natural disasters; physical, sexual and emotional abuse; domestic violence and being a victim of crime – a child is exposed to is associated with elevated concentrations of the major stress hormone, cortisol.
“There is also evidence that childhood maltreatment is associated with reduced brain volume and that these changes may be linked to anxiety.
“Looking at rats, we examined whether the impact of early life stress on the brain was exacerbated by drinking high volumes of sugary drinks after weaning.
“As females are more likely to experience adverse life events, we studied female Sprague-Dawley rats.
“To model early life trauma or abuse, after rats were born half of the litters were exposed to limited nesting material from days two to nine after birth. They then returned to normal bedding until they were weaned.
“The limited nesting alters maternal behaviour and increases anxiety in the offspring later in life.
“At weaning, half the rats were given unlimited access to low-fat chow and water to drink, while their sisters were given chow, water and a 25 per cent sugar solution that they could choose to drink.
“Animals exposed to early life stress were smaller at weaning, but this difference disappeared over time.
“Rats consuming sugar in both groups (control and stress) ate more calories over the experiment.
“The rats were followed until they were 15 weeks old, and then their brains were examined. As we know that early life stress can impact mental health and function, we examined a part of the brain called the hippocampus, which is important for both memory and stress.
“Four groups of rats were studied – control (no stress), control rats drinking sugar, rats exposed to stress, and rats exposed to stress who drank sugar.
“We found that chronic consumption of sugar in rats who were not stressed produced similar changes in the hippocampus as seen in the rats who were stressed but not drinking sugar.
“Early life stress exposure or sugar drinking led to lower expression of the receptor that binds the major stress hormone cortisol, which may affect the ability to recover from exposure to a stressful situation.
“Another gene that is important for the growth of nerves, Neurod1, was also reduced by both sugar and stress.
“Other genes important for the growth of nerves were investigated, and just drinking sugar from a young age was sufficient to reduce them.
“The rats were exposed to high sugar intakes during development, and the impact of the sugar is worrying as it may affect brain development, although further work is required to test this.
“In this study, combining sugar intake and early life stress did not produce further changes in the hippocampus, but whether this remains the case over time is unclear.
“The changes in the brain induced by sugar are of great concern given the high consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages, with particularly high consumption in children aged nine to 16 years.
“If similar processes are at play in humans to what was found in our rat study, reducing the consumption of sugar across the community is important.
“The fact that drinking sugar or exposure to early life stress reduced the expression of genes critical for brain development and growth is of great concern.
“While it is impossible to perform such studies in humans, the brain circuits controlling stress responses and feeding are conserved across species.
“People who were exposed to early life trauma have changes in the structure of their hippocampus. In humans, those consuming the most ‘western’ diet had smaller hippocampal volumes, in line with data from animal models. Taken together, these findings suggest future work should consider possible long-term effects of high sugar intake, particularly early in life, on the brain and behaviour.”
Changes to the brain region that controls emotional
behaviour and cognitive function were more extensive than those caused by early life stress.