8 Lunasol Intellectual Liquid Eyeliner, $30 (holder); $18.50 (refill)
USING IT: This was the thickest and softest brush. There wasn’t a true black shade in this collection; the closest was a brown-black with a matte finish. It was also the easiest to remove – no need to tug at my skin. STAY-ON POWER: By midday, the lines had smudged a little but this can be ignored if you’re not fussy. By day’s end, half the lines had smudged and transferred to the eyelid crease.