Essence Stays No Matter What 24h Waterproof Volume Mascara in Black, $5.90
USING IT: It needed three coats to achieve visibly thicker lashes, and it took longer to dry. I didn’t notice any clumping, but the mascara smudged slightly towards the end of the day. I had to be careful with the thick, bristly brush, in case I accidentally got mascara on my eyelids. EFFECT: My lashes looked obviously fuller and thicker. REMOVING IT: It came off with cleansing oil, not cleansing water, and needed five strokes of the cotton pad to come off completely.