What Qithi did wrong
Advocate Sicelo Mthethwa has strongly recommended that Boxing SA (BSA) fire its suspended CEO Moffat Qithi with immediate effect.
Mthethwa presided over Qithi’s disciplinary hearing that ended at the BSA offices in Pretoria on July 8.
The beleaguered Qithi was suspended by the BSA in 2013 for failing to disclose his criminal record when he applied for the R1 million-a-year job in 2011.
He has already been paid more than R200 000 in bonuses while on suspension for the past two years. Qithi received R101 067.88 for the 2013/14 financial year and R112 811 for the 2014/15 financial year.
Mthethwa, who chaired the proceedings, said he had found Qithi guilty on 11 charges.
The charges are clearly laid out in an explosive 127-page document, which was leaked to City Press this week.
The first charge is gross dishonesty in that Qithi failed to disclose his criminal record before he landed the plum job of CEO of the boxing governing body.
The charge sheet also found him guilty of bringing BSA’s name into disrepute in that he failed to disclose he had a criminal record for drunken driving.
Another charge, on which Mthethwa found
Gross dishonesty: Failing to disclose past criminal record;
Bringing the name of Boxing SA (BSA) into disrepute;
Contravening section 13 of the Boxing Act of 2001: Failure to sign performance agreement;
Gross insubordination: Refusal to sign performance agreement;
Fraud: Making unauthorised personal use of BSA credit card; Qithi guilty, was that of fraud in that Qithi made unauthorised personal use of a BSA credit card – the misuse is estimated at R20 930.
Mthethwa said Qithi used the employer’s credit card fraudulently to sustain his lifestyle while in the employ of the BSA.
Mthethwa added that Qithi’s employer – the BSA – fell under the auspices of the department of sport, arts, culture and recreation.
According to Mthethwa’s statement, hundreds of thousands of rands of taxpayers’ money was used to settle a defamation suit, which was brought against the BSA by boxing
Gross insubordination: Signing lease agreement;
Gross dishonesty: Misrepresentation regarding leasing of premises;
Gross dishonesty: Relating to misrepresentation;
Gross dishonesty: Relating to BSA credit card fraud;
Financial misconduct: Contravening the Public Finance Management Act; and
Gross misconduct: Dereliction of duty. promoter Branco Milenkovic.
In 2013, the South Gauteng High Court heard that Qithi’s appointment by the BSA was “irrational and unconstitutional”. This was during the Milenkovic court case.
Under the financial misconduct charge, which is a contravention of the Public Finance Management Act, Qithi was accused of causing the boxing association to lose R500 000 as a result of the “wrongful and defamatory statement made by yourself against Branco Milenkovic” on or about July 2012.
In his report on the findings of the disciplinary hearing, Mthethwa pointed out that:
Qithi’s conduct had caused great harm to the BSA;
He became a law unto himself and acted contrary to the instructions of the BSA board;
It is “my considered view that the prospects for the rehabilitation of Mr Qithi are negligible”; and
It is apparent that the employment relationship between Qithi and the BSA had broken down irretrievably.
According to Mthethwa’s verdict on the matter: “For the various reasons fully set out above, it is recommended that the services of the employee, Mr Qithi, with Boxing SA ought to be terminated with immediate effect.”
BSA board chairperson Ntambi Ravele said its members would deliberate on Mthethwa’s recommendations this week.
“The BSA is in possession of the report. We’ll study it and decide on the way forward,” she said.
Ravele said they hoped to soon finalise the matter of hiring a new CEO.
Qithi could not be reached for comment as his cellphone was “no longer in operation”.
When contacted for comment, Qithi’s lawyer, who Mthethwa said was named as S Nkonyeni in the hearing’s papers, said: “I am not mandated to talk to the media about my client.”
Nkonyeni also refused to provide City Press with Qithi’s new contact details.
Qithi iss appointed by During an extensive grilling Sport and Reecreation The South Gauteng Highh in court aboout his criminal record, it Minister Fikile Mbalula CCourtt hearhrs that Qithi’ss emerges that Qithi was charged and Boxing SA (BBSA) chief appointmment was founnd guilty of dishonesty, insuborofficer. His aappoint‘irrationall and dinW Walter nation Sisuluand gross University negligencein by ment comess two years uncconstitutionall’ after the uuring the MMthatha, where he worked as reesignation of defamation chief operating officer. He was BBongani caase of also previously convicted for Khumalo promoter BrBranco being in possession of stolen from the Milenkovic against property; of drunk driving; and same position Qithi and the BSA. oof drinking in public