A façade of unity in a sea of lobbying
Unity and cohesion remain the slogans for the ANC-led alliance as the three partners echo the claim of last week’s Cosatu special national congress that such togetherness has been assured. It hasn’t.
However, with the infighting having gone overwhelmingly in favour of the executive, there are hurried attempts to create a façade of unity as the lobbying continues.
The infighting, measured by the vote on the somewhat esoteric issue of credentials, largely went the way it did for three reasons:
Possibly substantial minorities in a number of unions could not, on a show of hands, go against their majorities;
The fact that expelled metal workers’ union Numsa, by encouraging the establishment of a United Front and a Socialist Movement, had moved into the political arena, directly opposing the ANC and the SA Communist Party (SACP); and
The executive argument that the reinstatement of both Numsa and expelled Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi could be raised at the federation’s scheduled congress in November.
To the forefront in congratulating the Cosatu majority on “building unity and cohesion”, obviously without Numsa and Vavi, is the SACP. In contrast, the ANC clearly would like to see both readmitted.
The SACP had also, only days before the Cosatu congress, completed its own special conference, called in the face of growing demands from rank and file members for the party to “go it alone” in elections. As with the schisms in the Cosatu unions, this is a manifestation of increasing levels of disillusionment with the ANC in government.
This disillusionment has also seen the SACP grow quite rapidly to a claimed 225 000 members. And it is many of these newer, younger, members, seeking an alternative to the present regime, who want the SACP to challenge for power on an alternative, “socialist” platform.
This attitude is understandable, since of the sixmember executive of the SACP, three are ministers, one is a deputy minister and one chairs the parliamentary portfolio committee on communications. The 11-strong Politburo contains the ANC secretary-general, the general secretary of Cosatu and the general secretary of the federation’s now largest affiliate, the National Education, Health and Allied Workers’ Union, along with two former government ministers and two members of Parliament.
Among the 22 current members of the party’s central committee, excluding the Politburo members, there are two national government ministers, three deputy ministers, the deputy speaker of Parliament and three MPs.
Given this degree of representation in the central body politic alone, it is little wonder that many SACP members feel that their party could stage a serious electoral challenge. But that is only because they think – as, officially, does Cosatu – that the SACP is a radical alternative to the ANC.
Yet leading figures in the SACP are all members of not only the ANC, but of government. As such, they are equally responsible for policies that their own party is supposed to oppose.
And although the ANC remains a member of the polyglot Socialist International, its policies are decidedly mainstream: “neoliberal” in current parlance.
So perhaps the SACP should adopt the socialist anthem, the Red Flag, but use the words: “The people’s flag is palest pink/ it’s not as red as some folk think.”