Cosatu’s support of Zuma led to ‘raw deal’
Trade federation Cosatu believes it was dealt a rotten hand after supporting President Jacob Zuma and his camp’s ascendancy to leadership at the ANC’s 2007 national conference in Polokwane. Cosatu, which was a key backer of Zuma before and after Polokwane, says it regrets being lulled into complacency and allowing “neoliberal policies” to continue.
In a draft secretariat report penned by Cosatu general secretary Bheki Ntshalintshali ahead of the four-day central committee sitting at the end of next month, the federation speaks of a “honeymoon period in which the left axis suspended its struggles and ... displayed blind loyalty, and invested its political fortunes to the Polokwane outcomes and later in Mangaung”.
In 2012, Zuma secured a second term as ANC president during the party’s conference in Mangaung.
The report harshly criticises the ANC-led government for failing to transform the apartheid economy.
“The left forces in South Africa led a charge that led to the sweeping changes in Polokwane and dislodged, but did not defeat, the ideologues of neoliberalism inside the movement,” reads the document.
“In the process, the left axis was wittingly or unwittingly co-opted as spokespeople and apologists to explain the failures of the neoliberal policies in the hope that things were going to change for the better.”
Cosatu says the implementation of the Polokwane resolutions and election manifesto commitments were substituted with cosmetic changes that did not tamper with the “fundamental structure of the apartheid and colonial economy”.
Instead, the ANC and its allies were distracted by a series of mistakes that placed the governing party on the back foot. These mistakes contributed to growing Declining membership among its industrial affiliates is giving Cosatu headaches.
The draft secretariat report penned by general secretary Bheki Ntshalintshali shows this could alter the character of the federation.
By 2012, private sector membership had dropped to 61%, while that of the public sector had risen to 39%.
The situation is now far worse because, since then, its biggest affiliate – the National Union of Metalworkers of SA – has been expelled and the Food and Allied Workers’ Union followed the metalworkers to the new federation Saftu, headed by former Cosatu general secretary Zwelinzima Vavi.
The Cosatu report flashes warning lights that this change in dynamics could weaken the federation. discontent, a sense of alienation, frustration, disappointment and despair among South Africans. Ntshalintshali uses the handling of the Nkandla scandal as an example, and he says it should never have happened in the first place. Still, the alliance, in particular the ANC, refused to learn from its mistakes.
“The Constitutional Court judgment on the Nkandla report by the Public Protector that ruled against the country’s president has also created a situation in which the revolution as a whole has been put on the back foot,” Ntshalintshali writes.
His report comes as the leadership battles to contain affiliates’ objections to Zuma speaking at Cosatu’s Worker’s Day celebrations in the Free State. Traditionally, the president of the ANC speaks at the rally alongside the leaders of Cosatu and the SA Communist Party (SACP).
This week, the National Education, Health and Allied Workers’ Union and the SA Democratic Teachers’ Union called on the federation’s top leaders to bar Zuma from the rally in line with a recent central executive committee decision that the president resign from office. They were joined by the smaller but vocal
Two years ago, ANC secretary-general Gwede Mantashe earned the wrath of public sector unions when he warned that, once the trade union federation slanted towards the civil service, it would be in trouble. The concern in Cosatu circles is that, because industrial workers are at the coalface of exploitation, they will probably be more militant. The dominance by public sector unions could weaken its stance.
Cosatu’s membership stands at about 1.7 million. About 2.8 million workers belong to unions that are not affiliated to Cosatu. This means Cosatu has failed to fulfil its 2003 national congress resolution of increasing membership by 10% every year.
Cosatu is worried about the fact that 73% of workers in South Africa are disorganised; that affiliates are Commercial Workers’ Union. Cosatu’s officials have responded by saying the decision only related to Zuma’s presidency of the republic, so the ANC was free to deploy him to the rally.
Amid concerns that Zuma could be booed, Cosatu has asked its members to apply maximum discipline.
Cosatu’s strong stance, the secretariat report reveals, relates to a number of developments that have rattled South Africa. These include Zuma’s recent Cabinet reshuffle, which happened without consultation of alliance partners and without consensus from the ANC top six, and the Public Protector’s State of Capture report, which raised questions about how the Gupta family had captured some sections of the state, including Zuma.
Others are the alleged abuse of state security agencies, the accusation and later withdrawal of charges against axed finance minister Pravin Gordhan, the current contested regional and provincial conferences in KwaZulu-Natal, and the accompanying political assassinations there.
Cosatu also bemoans the functioning of the alliance, which it says exists in speeches only, and poaching members from each other; that there is a muting of Cosatu national office bearers who intervene in affiliates as they are subtly threatened with removal from office; and that there is a growing “self-serving” culture among leaders and personnel.
To deal with its cash crunch and prevent splurging on congresses, the report proposes the possibility of having in-house Cosatu conference facilities.
In addition, the federation’s detractors have identified Cosatu’s weaknesses.
“The biggest danger we face today is that we have exposed our acute weaknesses to our class adversaries and detractors in the name of being open and transparent, but we did so without addressing our weaknesses adequately,” Ntshalintshali writes. not in decision-making and implementation of policy.
“It is not obvious that consensus policy positions that emerge from alliance deliberations find expression in ANC policy directives, nor is it obvious that ANC policy directives will find expression in government policy. It is also not obvious that government policy will be implemented by the state bureaucracy,” it says.
In Cosatu’s eyes, the battles leading up to the ANC’s national conference have led to the SACP being “identified as a strategic impediment to be dealt with”.
The document refers to a “political stampede”, where everyone is jostling for power. It highlights how the succession battles “have become even more acute, brutal, destructive and sharper” as leaders in the ANC plot against each other.
TALK TO US What should Cosatu do now that it has realised its mistake?
SMS us on 35697 using the keyword COSATU. Please include your name and province. SMSes cost R1.50
HITTING THE TRAIL Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa may have been campaigning for the ANC to take the Nquthu Local Municipality during his four-day visit to KwaZulu-Natal, but he also tested the waters for his own presidential campaign. He punted the ANC hard during a visit to Nquthu, the official start of the ANC’s campaign to win the hung municipality. He also took time to speak at an SA National Civic Organisation event in nearby Newcastle, in the ANC’s Emalahleni region, where he contradicted President Jacob Zuma’s dismissal of recent marches at which Zuma was called on to step down. At the event on Friday night, which was called in memory of Chris Hani, Ramaphosa said that it was a ‘disgrace’ that people were marching against the ANC, which previously united the country and its people, ‘because they can see that the ANC is not doing a good job. Our response as the ANC should not and cannot be to dismiss those people and think that they are crazy. Those people are not crazy. They are reacting they way they are because it is not right.’ Ramaphosa said the ANC was paying the price for wrongdoing because opposition parties took advantage of such weaknesses. ‘The opposition parties can see that the ANC is wounded. Now they think that they can take the ANC on. If we are not careful, indeed, they can take us on.’ By yesterday morning, the backlash had begun against Ramaphosa, who had a public and friendly chat with ousted KwaZulu-Natal ANC chairperson Senzo Mchunu and former provincial economic development MEC Mike Mabuyakhulu at the Newcastle meeting. The province is yet to declare its chosen presidential candidate, but its youth league and the Durban ANC region openly back Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma. Other provincial leaders are also trying to line up their regions behind her, but several are contested, including Emalahleni and Inkosi Bambatha, under which Nquthu falls. KwaZulu-Natal ANC spokesperson Mdumiseni Ntuli questioned why Ramaphosa addressed the meeting without consulting provincial leaders, saying the meeting was called by ‘people who are not concerned about the unity of the movement’