Canadian potash venture under fire
BHP BILLITON’S plan to enter the potash market with a contentious $13 billion (R169.22bn) project in Canada is adding to challenges facing the incoming chairperson of the world biggest mining company. Ken MacKenzie, a 53-year-old board member who takes up the role in September, currently is on a global tour to meet investors in the wake of an activist campaign in recent months spearheaded by Elliott Management. Issues of concern for some shareholders include the producer’s US onshore oil and gas assets and its plans to accelerate the Jansen potash venture. Proceeding with Jansen risks a “severe strategic misstep,” according to Sanford C Bernstein analyst Paul Gait, as the new supply would risk depressing prices by delaying to about 2036 the ability of the potash market to work through overcapacity. Paul Singer’s Elliott went public in April with a campaign seeking asset sales and a corporate overhaul, claiming management decisions have eroded as much as $40bn in value. “Potash is going to be a big, big decision and I get the feeling most people in the market are fairly cautious,” said Andy Forster, senior investment officer at Argo Investments, which manages more than A$5bn (R51bn) and holds BHP’s Sydney-listed shares. Investors are looking to MacKenzie to show he’ll be “more disciplined in the capital-allocation process,” he said. BHP declined to comment on talks with investors on the Jansen project. Potash demand could double by the late 2040s to develop into a $50bn market, Paul Burnside, BHP’s principal, potash analysis, said yesterday in a blog post on the company’s website.