Boston bomber apologizes but death sentence stands
Boston bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev apologized to his victims for the first time at a highly emotional court hearing Wednesday where he was formally sentenced to death for the 2013 attacks.
The U.S. citizen of Chechen descent was sentenced to death on six counts for perpetrating the Marathon bombings, one of the bloodiest assaults on U.S. soil since the September 11, 2001 attacks.
“I would like to now apologize to the victims and to the survivors,” said the 21-year-old former university student in his first public remarks since the April 15, 2013 bombings that killed three people.
“I am guilty,” he said in a slight Russian accent, standing pale and thin in a dark blazer. “Let there be no doubt about that.”
“I am sorry for the lives I have taken, for the suffering, the damage that I have done,” he said, couching his remarks in the name of Allah and asking for God’s forgiveness.
Judge George O’Toole officially imposed the death sentence, which had been reached unanimously by a 12-person jury on May 15 after prosecutors painted Tsarnaev as a remorseless terrorist.
“I sentence you to the penalty of death by execution,” O’Toole told Tsarnaev, before he was led away by U.S. Marshals.
Tsarnaev will eventually sit on federal death row in Terre Haute, Indiana, but prosecutors say he could be sent first to America’s only “super-max” prison, ADX Florence, in Colorado.
Defense lawyer Judy Clarke told the court that Tsarnaev had offered to plead guilty last year, but Wednesday’s remarks were the first time that her client had expressed any remorse in public.
‘I have forgiven him’
Survivors were divided on whether his apology was genuine. Lynn Julian said his remarks “were sort of shocking” and denied that he had shown proper remorse or regret.
“A sincere apology would’ve been nice,” she told reporters.
But Henry Borgard, who was a student on his way home from work when he was injured in the bombings, was one of the few to forgive and said that he had been “really deeply moved” by Tsarnaev’s remarks.
“I have forgiven him. I have come to a place of peace and I genuinely hope that he does as well,” he said. “I’m going to take it on faith that what he said was genuine.”
But government prosecutors criticized Tsarnaev, who showed little emotion during the trial, for invoking Allah, and said he had not renounced terrorism or repudiated violent extremism.
On Wednesday 24 victims and their relatives made harrowing impact statements, some in tears, as they described their grief, pain, financial problems and how the attacks brutally changed their lives.
Outside the court house, police arrested a young man who allegedly had a meat cleaver stashed in his car. He is being investigated for any possible terrorism link, the FBI said.
The bombings wounded 264 people, including 17 who lost limbs, near the finish line at the northeastern city’s popular marathon.
“The choices you made were despicable,” said Patricia Campbell, whose daughter Krystle was killed.
“What you did to my daughter was disgusting. The jury did the right thing,” she said, addressing Tsarnaev directly.
‘All on him’
Bill Richard, the father of the youngest victim, eight-year-old Martin, said he would have preferred Tsarnaev receive a life sentence but said the attacks were “all on him.”
Tsarnaev, Richard said, could have stopped his brother, changed his mind and “walked away with a minimal sense of humanity.”
“He chose hate. He chose destruction. He chose death,” Richard said. “We choose love. We choose kindness. We choose peace. That is what makes us different.”
The judge told Tsarnaev that his name would only ever be remembered for the horrors that he inflicted.
The death penalty verdict was a stinging defeat for the defense, who argued that Tsarnaev was a “lost kid” who had been manipulated by his older brother, Tamerlan.
Tamerlan was shot dead on the run before Tsarnaev was arrested.
He was found, injured, in a grounded boat on which he had scrawled a bloody message defending the attacks as a means to avenge U.S. wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The death sentence is possible only under federal law. The state of Massachusetts outlawed capital punishment in 1947 and opinion polls had suggested residents favored a life sentence for Tsarnaev.
Boston Marathon bombing survivors Erika Brannock, left, and Rebekah Gregory leave the Moakley Federal Courthouse clutching each other following the formal sentencing of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev in Boston, Wednesday, June 24.