RUNNERS-UP

Marks & Spencer Autograph Freedom Roses

marksandspencer.com, £35 with free delivery, £2.92 a bloom

Stunning roses with pretty sprigs of salal and eucalyptus. Sumptuous flower heads. Gift card underwhelming. Lasted 10 days.

79/100

Moonpig Luxury Red Roses

moonpig.com, £32 with free delivery, £2.67 a bloom

Pretty Naomi roses with stems of eucalyptus robusta. Heads were slightly different sizes. Looked better after a few days, when fully opened. Lasted 10 days.

77/100

Teleflorist Red Roses

teleflorist.co.uk, £27.99 with £3.99 delivery, £2.67 a bloom

Even-sized, long-stemmed Freedom roses. Full heads of velvety petals. Good-quality roses opened to a good size after a few days. Some leaves torn and broken. Lasted nine days.

70/100

Flowers Direct Pure Red Roses Delight

£25 with free delivery, £2.08 a bloom

Hand-tied bouquet of even-sized Grand Prix roses. Good value. Some leaves appeared a bit mottled. Lasted nine days.

66/100