Improvement isn’t keep­ing sta­tus quo

The Press and Journal (Highlands & Islands) - - FEATURES -

SIR, – The piece on “New high-speed trains” (Press and Jour­nal, Septem­ber 15) makes in­ter­est­ing read­ing. Leav­ing aside the dis­cus­sion over whether the trains are “new” or “re­fur­bished” there are still a num­ber of points that bear fur­ther ex­am­i­na­tion.

First, if I re­call cor­rectly, Abel­lio, when they took over the ScotRail fran­chise, promised new and bet­ter trains. Yet ScotRail Al­liance manag­ing di­rec­tor Alex Haynes has now said “I can ab­so­lutely guar­an­tee that it will be no WORSE than it is to­day”.

This is sim­ply not good enough,

the prom­ise was for im­prove­ments not a main­te­nance of the sta­tus quo!

Se­condly, ex­ist­ing HST trains are bet­ter than DMUs be­cause they have more toi­let pro­vi­sion, legroom and bike space.

ScotRail plans to add more seats to the car­riages by re­mov­ing toi­lets and de­creas­ing bike space and pos­si­bly legroom – would it not be bet­ter to add an ex­tra car­riage and re­tain the toi­lets, legroom and bike space?

Fi­nally, while the lim­ited im­prove­ments on the Aberdeen to In­ver­ness, Glas­gow and Ed­in­burgh jour­neys are to be wel­comed, al­ways as­sum­ing that th­ese jour­neys are cov­ered by the HST fleet, what of those com­mut­ing from say Huntly, In­verurie, Stone­haven and Lau­rencekirk to Aberdeen?

Will they al­ways see HSTs or will the class 170 & 158 DMUs sol­dier wearily on?

Abel­lio promised great things for ScotRail pas­sen­gers and while the Glas­gow and Ed­in­burgh rail users may be about to see some of th­ese things ar­rive, Aberdeen and the north-east are as usual left wait­ing on the plat­form.

Graham Bar­ron, Southview,

Drum of War­tle

What a nasty man and to use that vow added by the Chris­tian church at mar­riage, that a woman must obey a man, and how dare he use it against his wife in court. Will this quash his sen­tence, will to­day’s court agree with the church’s vow?

Lynne Digby

Wot a hor­ri­ble beast hope the poor woman can find a way to get on with her life & gets help to re­cover from the men­tal tor­ture

He­len Camp­bell

Just read about it in the pa­per am sur­prised she is still liv­ing af­ter what this evil man put her through

Nic Turn­bull

No words can dis­cribe this man. Poor woman. Hope she gets jus­tice.

Irene Caro­line Hingston Black

Face­book: face­book.com/ The Press and Jour­nal/ Twit­ter: @pressjour­nal

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from UK

© PressReader. All rights reserved.