Another model

The debate over whether public services are better in private or public hands needs to take note of an alternative halfway house as demonstrated in Scottish Water. This is a statutory corporation created (in 2000) and owned by the state and responsible to the Scottish Government. But it is also a private limited company. Apparently, the Water Industry Commission is pleased with its performance and the company’s finances outperform. It is not funded by the Government and makes an annual surplus, paying tax.

Perhaps this model should be followed elsewhere.

STEUART CAMPBELL Dovecot Loan, Edinburgh