BEST ICE CREAM
370 RIVER ROAD, NEW MILFORD (201) 265-5505, BRAINFREEZENJ.COM
Don’t let the name of the shop deter you – BrainFreeze is just the place to go for a delicious scoop of ice cream. Named for its signature treat, the shop serves Nasto’s brand ice cream in endless flavors including cotton candy, which is a popular favorite.
RUNNERS-UP: BISCHOFF’S TEANECK CONRAD’S WESTWOOD VAN DYK’S RIDGEWOOD