Trump’s Mideast ties cast doubts on motives
Business connections in Persian Gulf present conflicts of interest
LONDON — President Donald Trump has done business with royals from Saudi Arabia for at least 20 years, since he sold the Plaza Hotel to a partnership formed by a Saudi prince. Trump has earned millions of dollars from the United Arab Emirates for putting his name on a golf course, with a second soon to open.
He has never entered the booming market in neighboring Qatar, however, despite years of trying.
Now a feud has broken out among these three crucial U.S. allies, and Trump has thrown his weight firmly behind the two countries where he has business ties, raising new concerns about the appearance of a conflict between his public role and his financial incentives.
Trump has said he is backing Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates because Qatar is “a funder of terror at a very high level.” But his stance toward Qatar, which is host to the largest U.S. air base in the region, has differed sharply from the positions of the Pentagon and State Department. The secretaries of defense and state have stayed neutral, urging unity against the common enemy of the Islamic State.
Conflict of interest
Trump is the first president in 40 years to retain his personal business interests after entering the White House. Other senior officials in the executive branch are required to divest their assets. Critics say his singular decision to hold on to his global business empire inevitably casts a doubt on his motives, especially when his public actions dovetail with his business interests.
“Other countries in the Middle East see what is happening and may think, ‘We should be opening golf courses’ or ‘We should be buying rooms at the Trump International,’” said Brian Egan, a State Department legal adviser under the Obama administration. “Even if there is no nefarious intent on behalf of the president or the Trumps, for a president to be making money from business holdings in sensitive places around the world is likely to have an impact.”
A spokesman for the White House declined to address questions about the appearance of a conflict of interest. The spokesman, Michael Short, said in an email only that Trump had “formally extracted himself ” from management of his business, the Trump Organization.
Stepping away from management without giving up ownership does not diminish Trump’s financial incentives or conflicts, as the director of the Office of Government Ethics warned before Trump’s inauguration.
‘The time has come’
The feud in the Persian Gulf flared up on June 5, when Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Arab allies all broke off trade, travel and diplomatic relations with Qatar as punishment for what they said was its support of terrorism. Scholars of the region and American diplomats, however, said the dispute appeared to have more to do with jostling over power and autonomy.
The U.S. ambassador to Qatar, Dana Shell Smith, responded to the showdown by retweeting a statement from the U.S. Treasury praising Qatar for cracking down on extremist financing. “Great partnership, real progress,” she wrote. (She stepped down a few days later, a move that the State Department said she had planned long ago.)
A few days later, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson called on Qatar “to be responsive to the concerns of its neighbors.” But he added, “We call on the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Egypt to ease the blockade against Qatar.” He noted that the dispute was impairing international trade and hindering the military campaign against the Islamic State.
Trump, on the other hand, endorsed the blockade as soon as it started. He had returned days earlier from a summit meeting in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, with the leaders of all the gulf states, and he declared on Twitter that his visit was “already paying off.”
Then Trump defended the blockade again just hours after Tillerson had urged an end to it. “The time had come to call on Qatar to end its funding” of terrorism, Trump said.
Golf communities
Trump made his first deal in Dubai, in the United Arab Emirates, in 2005, to build a hotel with a state-owned developer. He pulled out after the 2008 recession, but by 2010 Trump and two of his children, Ivanka and Donald Jr., were back in the region scouting for new business.
Donald Trump linked up in 2013 with Hussain Sajwani, a developer sometimes referred to as the Donald of Dubai. All big real estate developers in the United Arab Emirates are acutely dependent on the country’s rulers, who can authorize or block their projects.
Trump agreed to manage a golf course as part of a development built by Damac, Sajwani’s company. Trump hung billboards of Ivanka, a former model and executive for his company, all over the city to sell properties, and he pronounced it “the greatest golf community in Asia.” In 2014, he agreed to manage a second course with Sajwani.
The golf courses paid Donald Trump $2 million to $10 million even before they opened, according to financial disclosure forms filed in May 2016. Then, after Trump’s election as president, Sajwani offered to pay him an additional $2 billion to develop more properties. Sajwani’s company did not respond to messages.
As president-elect, Trump said he had declined. “I did not have to turn it down,” he said in January, noting that presidents are exempt from ethics laws barring such conflicts.
When Sajwani attended Trump’s New Year’s Eve party at his Mar-a-Lago resort, Trump praised the Sajwani family as “beautiful people.”
A few weeks later, his sons Donald Jr. and Eric attended the opening of the first Dubai golf course, and on May 16, Sajwani posted an Instagram photo of himself dining with Donald Trump Jr. in Dubai. They discussed “new ideas and innovation,” Sajwani wrote.
Fall in revenue
In a financial disclosure form released Friday, Trump reported a sharp drop in his Dubai income, to about $13,000 over roughly 16 months.
The Trump Organization dissolved subsidiaries created to pursue business opportunities in Qatar six days after Trump was inaugurated. The four subsidiaries are DT Marks Qatar LLC, DT Marks Qatar Member Corp., THC Qatar Hotel Manager LLC and THC Qatar Hotel Manager Member Corp.
The second Trump golf course is expected to open in 2018.