New York Post

Outrage at FDNY hero split

Separate wall for 9/11 cancer vics s

- By SUSAN EDELMAN sedelman@nypost.com

The FDNY will not change a controvers­ial practice that has some firefighte­rs fuming — honoring those who die of 9/11-related illness on a different memorial wall than those killed while on duty.

The FDNY has two separate walls in the lobby of its Brooklyn headquarte­rs: One prominent display honors members who died “in the line of duty,” including those who perished on 9/11.

A separate wall near the security desk names the Bravest who have succumbed to cancer and other illnesses linked to the toxic Ground Zero pit where rescuers toiled.

Some firefighte­rs are angered because the NYPD, in contrast, adds the names of officers who die of 9/11linked disease to its Wall of Honor along with all cops killed in the line of duty.

But Fire Commission­er Daniel Nigro issued a message to members last week saying he sees no reason to change course.

“I respectful­ly disagree with those who may believe that our members are treated differentl­y than ‘all the other first responders,’ ” he wrote.

The FDNY does not consider firefighte­rs who succumb to 9/11-related cancers or other ailments “line of duty deaths.”

Instead, their deaths are labeled “administra­tive” line of duty.

To many firefighte­rs sick- ened after serving at Ground Zero, “it’s insult-ting,” said John Feal, an ad-dvocate for 9/11 first re-esponders

“Last I checked, thesese firefighte­rs were heroes,”s,” he said. “We want to get thisis changed.”

The 9/11 attacks killed 34343 FDNY firefighte­rs.

Last September, thehe FDNY added 17 names to a list of Bravest who haveve died of 9/11-related illness,s, bringing the total to 127.

But the total number of all 9/11 responders, includingn­g firefighte­rs, who have beenen diagnosed with WTClinked cancers now exceeds 5,100, records show.

Late firefighte­r John MacNamara, who logged 500 hours searching for victims at Ground Zero and died of advanced colon can-ncer in 2009 at age 41, left aa wife and then 2-year-oldld son, Jack.

His widow, Jennifer Siegelel MacNamara, who started a foundation in his honor, hasas mixed feelings.

“John died in the line of duty, and we all know that,”t,” she told The Post. “Wherere his name appears on a me-emorial is not the most important thing.”

In his message, Nigro also said the department willill not issue a special citywidede “5-5-5-5 radio notificati­on”n” to honor a member whoho dies of World Trade Center sickness.

“We have reserved that profound signal for announcing ‘traditiona­l’ line of duty deaths,” he said.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States