The Grand Theft Auto Killers

The mys­te­ri­ous rise and fall of Moscow’s most no­to­ri­ous gang


The mys­te­ri­ous rise and fall of the no­to­ri­ous Moscow gang charged with one of the most hor­rific killing sprees in Rus­sian his­tory.

It was a dar­ing es­cape plan, one that started in the el­e­va­tor of a Moscow court­house. On Au­gust 1, two Rus­sian po­lice of­fi­cers were lead­ing five mur­der sus­pects to a court hear­ing. But as the el­e­va­tor as­cended, in­ves­ti­ga­tors say, one suspect—his hands cuffed in front of him—be­gan to choke an of­fi­cer from be­hind, while his fel­low de­fen­dants swiftly dis­armed the other.

Clutch­ing their newly ac­quired weapons, the men burst out of the el­e­va­tor on the third floor of the court­house and be­gan fir­ing at mem­bers of Rus­sia’s Na­tional Guard, but the state se­cu­rity force quickly over­whelmed the pris­on­ers. Three sus­pects were killed in the gun bat­tle; an­other two suf­fered se­ri­ous in­juries, and one would later die in a Moscow hos­pi­tal. Rus­sian tele­vi­sion soon aired footage of the sus­pects ly­ing in pools of their own blood. “Is that one alive or dead?” said an off-cam­era voice, as se­cu­rity of­fi­cers stood guard over the crime scene.

The five men who at­tempted that es­cape had all been charged with a spate of bru­tal mur­ders on the high­ways around Moscow. It was one of the most hor­rific killing sprees in Rus­sia un­der Vladimir Putin. It was also one of the most mys­ti­fy­ing, giv­ing rise to ex­plo­sive ru­mors of high-level cover-ups and ter­ri­ble vengeance. Al­most three years on, the ru­mors just won’t go away—and with good rea­son.

Corpses on the High­way

in­ves­ti­ga­tors say the killings be­gan on may 3, 2014, when Ana­toly Lebe­dev and his wife, Ta­tiana, both in their 60s, were driv­ing south on the M4, a 950-mile-long high­way that winds through Rus­sia’s agri­cul­tural heart­land. It was dark, and they had been trav­el­ing for around an hour when Ana­toly re­al­ized one of his tires was de­flat­ing. He pulled over and dis­cov­ered a hole. As he was tak­ing a tire jack out of the trunk, at least two gun­men ap­peared, fir­ing four shots from two 9 mm hand­guns, killing Ana­toly where he stood and Ta­tiana, who was in the pas­sen­ger seat. Then the at­tack­ers van­ished, leav­ing the cou­ple’s car by the side of the road.

The next to die was Alexei Tsiganov, a 53-year-old bus driver, who was gunned down on the M4 two months later. In Au­gust, the life­less body of Al­bert Yusupov, a 31-year-old for­mer dancer, was dis­cov­ered ly­ing next to his car on a road near Moscow. He had been shot in the head and back. Both men’s cars had flat tires. And so it went. By the fall, the num­ber of killings on and around the M4 had hit dou­ble dig­its. Some re­ports said the gang had taken the lives of as many as 26 mo­torists.

State me­dia and pro-krem­lin news web­sites, cit­ing sources in the se­cu­rity ser­vices, re­ported that few if any valu­ables were taken from the vic­tims—so rob­bery wasn’t the likely mo­tive. Rus­sian me­dia quickly dubbed the mys­te­ri­ous gun­men the GTA gang, a ref­er­ence to the Grand Theft Auto video games, in which play­ers en­gage in ran­dom acts of vi­o­lence.

The gang’s tac­tics were sim­ple and bru­tal, in­ves­ti­ga­tors say. The killers placed a chain of metal spikes on roads near Moscow, usu­ally, but not al­ways, on the M4. Then, they waited for a car to drive over them. When the driv­ers emerged from their ve­hi­cles to check the dam­age, the gang moved in, shoot­ing its vic­tims with skill and pre­ci­sion.

Some mo­torists were lucky enough to es­cape. Irina was trav­el­ing south from Moscow on the M4 one night in July 2014 when her dash­board

in­di­ca­tor showed that her left rear tire was losing air. She pulled over but did not leave the car im­me­di­ately. That de­ci­sion saved her life. “I saw the sil­hou­ettes of a num­ber of men,” says Irina, who asked me not to re­veal her true iden­tity. “One of them be­gan run­ning to­ward the car. I saw him take a hand­gun out of his jacket. An­other had a knife.”

Ter­ri­fied, Irina sped away. She called the po­lice on her cell­phone and gave them her GPS co­or­di­nates. Within min­utes, of­fi­cers ar­rived at the scene but dis­cov­ered noth­ing.

With the au­thor­i­ties un­able to stop the slaugh­ter, spec­u­la­tion mounted. One the­ory, pushed by Rus­sian na­tion­al­ists: Ukrainian au­thor­i­ties had hired killers to wreak havoc on or­di­nary Rus­sians. The mo­tive, the the­ory went, was re­venge for the Krem­lin’s seizure of Crimea ear­lier that year. Oth­ers al­leged the gang was made up of rogue mem­bers of the Rus­sian spe­cial forces, cit­ing un­con­firmed ru­mors the at­tack­ers used bul­lets avail­able only to the se­cu­rity ser­vices. Vladimir Yakhnenko, a lec­turer at Moscow State Univer­sity, sug­gested the killers were devil wor­ship­pers, be­cause the metal spikes the gang used to dis­able their vic­tims’ cars were in the shape of black crosses.

In Oc­to­ber 2014, around 150 armed vig­i­lantes launched nightly pa­trols of the roads around Moscow, stop­ping sus­pi­cious ve­hi­cles and ques­tion­ing driv­ers. “Th­ese killers aren’t just some cra­zies,” Erik Da­vidich, the leader of the vig­i­lantes, told me ahead of one pa­trol. “They are far too well or­ga­nized and pro­fes­sional for that,” he claimed. “In one case, three of them fired si­mul­ta­ne­ously from around [32 feet] away straight into the head of a driver. In the dark.”

Da­vidich and his vig­i­lantes didn’t catch the gang, but from the mo­ment they be­gan guard­ing the high­ways, not a sin­gle re­lated shoot­ing was re­ported. The GTA gang’s killing spree had come to an end.

But the mys­tery sur­round­ing the death and de­struc­tion it had left be­hind was far from over.

The Rus­sian Zom­bie Box

udel­naya is a quiet, al­most idyl­lic vil­lage some 25 miles from the Rus­sian cap­i­tal. It is pop­u­lar with wealthy Mus­covites, who come on week­ends to re­lax in two- or three-story homes sur­rounded by tall fences. Ex­pen­sive, for­eign-made ve­hi­cles glide through its tree-lined streets, many of which are named after Rus­sian writ­ers.

Early on Novem­ber 6, 2014, while it was still dark, a heav­ily armed spe­cial forces unit ar­rived in Udel­naya. Its target, at the rear of a residential com­pound, was a build­ing that was home to a 35-year-old Kyr­gyzs­tan na­tional named Ibay­dullo Subkhanov, along with his wife, her mother and the cou­ple’s two small chil­dren.

The spe­cial forces called for every­one in­side to come out with their hands raised. The women and chil­dren com­plied. Subkhanov didn’t. In­stead, he opened fire with a hand­gun, in­ves­ti­ga­tors said, and threw an ex­plo­sive de­vice at the of­fi­cers, who re­sponded with a lethal bar­rage of gun­shots and grenades. Subkhanov was killed in­stantly, and the build­ing was burned to the ground. The au­thor­i­ties later searched the prop­erty and found dozens of weapons, in­clud­ing AK-47 as­sault ri­fles, Brown­ing semi-au­to­matic hand­guns and bombs.

In­ves­ti­ga­tors later said Subkhanov was the leader of the in­fa­mous GTA gang. Peo­ple in the vil­lage were shocked. “We didn’t know any­thing about the gang


un­til we heard gun­fire and ex­plo­sions and saw all the smoke,” a neigh­bor told me when I vis­ited Udel­naya.

Over the next few weeks, Rus­sian au­thor­i­ties ar­rested nine al­leged gang mem­bers, charg­ing them with 17 mur­ders. The sus­pects were mi­grant work­ers from Kyr­gyzs­tan, Ta­jik­istan and Uzbek­istan—all mainly Mus­lim for­mer Soviet states in Cen­tral Asia. Like most of the mil­lions of mi­grant work­ers who come from poor coun­tries to work in Rus­sia, they all had low-pay­ing jobs. Some were jan­i­tors, oth­ers un­loaded trucks or did gru­el­ing man­ual la­bor on con­struc­tion sites.

Subkhanov had been a main­te­nance man on the Udel­naya com­pound. In a bizarre twist, the prop­erty he was liv­ing on be­longed to the fam­ily of Alexei Staroverov, a high-rank­ing of­fi­cial with the Rus­sian prose­cu­tor gen­eral’s of­fice. Even veteran Rus­sian jour­nal­ists were taken aback by the news: How was the sus­pected leader of one of the most vi­cious gangs in Rus­sia liv­ing at the home of a se­nior law en­force­ment of­fi­cial?

Staroverov de­nied any knowl­edge of the gang. He said he rarely vis­ited the prop­erty and had never met Subkhanov. But some doubted he was telling the truth, point­ing to his al­legedly du­bi­ous fi­nances as ev­i­dence of men­dac­ity. (De­spite his mod­est salary, Staroverov had once been named by

Forbes as one of Rus­sia’s rich­est se­cu­rity of­fi­cials.) In­ves­ti­ga­tors ul­ti­mately opened a crim­i­nal case against him on arms traf­fick­ing charges over the weapons dis­cov­ered on his prop­erty, but Vik­tor Grin, Rus­sia’s deputy prose­cu­tor gen­eral, quickly or­dered those charges to be dropped.

The link be­tween Staroverov and the gang should have been one of the big­gest sto­ries of the year, but it was mostly ig­nored by the pro-krem­lin me­dia. “The Zom­bie Box has gone quiet and is mak­ing out like it hasn’t no­ticed any­thing,” wrote Alexei Navalny, the Rus­sian op­po­si­tion leader, us­ing a pop­u­lar slang term for state tele­vi­sion.

After ques­tion­ing Staroverov, in­ves­ti­ga­tors ruled it was mere co­in­ci­dence that the al­leged ring­leader of the gang had lived on his prop­erty. He qui­etly re­signed his post, and his where­abouts are now un­clear. Al­though many ques­tioned the of­fi­cial story, there was no clear ex­pla­na­tion as to why he would have got­ten in­volved with the gang.

Yet sus­pi­cions linger. “I sim­ply don’t be­lieve in co­in­ci­dences of this kind,” says Dmitry Alyaev, a jour­nal­ist with Fer­gana, the Moscow-based news web­site, which re­ports on Cen­tral Asian is­sues. “There’s some­thing ex­tremely bizarre about all this.”

‘They Killed Com­plete Strangers’

the strange­ness didn’t end with staroverov. Within days of the ar­rests, Putin con­grat­u­lated po­lice on their good work. “This was a ter­ror­ist crime,” he told In­te­rior Min­istry head Vladimir Kolokolt­sev on Novem­ber 8, 2014. State me­dia echoed his com­ments. The Rus­sian gov­ern­ment’s of­fi­cial news­pa­per, Ros­siyskaya Gazeta, cited law en­force­ment sources as say­ing the mur­der sus­pects were Is­lamist rad­i­cals. “Those who have been ar­rested weren’t shoot­ing or cut­ting peo­ple up for money,” the news­pa­per wrote. “They killed com­plete strangers—un­be­liev­ers—for the sake of their ide­ol­ogy.” Pro-krem­lin me­dia also re­ported that Subkhanov, the gang’s al­leged leader, had briefly fought for the Is­lamic State group in Syria (ISIS).

This would not have been the first time that Is­lamist mil­i­tant groups had tar­geted Rus­sia. Bomb­ings claimed by the Cau­ca­sus Emi­rate ji­hadi group had torn through a high-speed train trav­el­ing from Moscow to St. Peters­burg in 2009, as well as metro sta­tions in Moscow the fol­low­ing year. The group also said it car­ried out a suicide at­tack at the cap­i­tal city’s Do­mode­dovo In­ter­na­tional Air­port in 2011. Suicide bombers also struck Vol­gograd, a city in the south, ahead of the 2014 Win­ter Olympics.

Yet within days of the GTA gang’s ar­rest, the In­ves­tiga­tive Com­mit­tee, an Fbi-style law en­force­ment agency that an­swers only to Putin, de­clared the killings noth­ing more than an ex­tremely vi­o­lent form of high­way rob­bery. “The mem­bers of the gang were mo­ti­vated only by greed,” Vladimir Markin, the com­mit­tee’s spokesman, said on Novem­ber 12, 2014.

It was a con­clu­sion that was in­con­sis­tent with ev­ery­thing known about the at­tacks. Ac­cord­ing to the of­fi­cial in­dict­ment, re­ported on in de­tail by Rus­sia’s Me­di­a­zona web­site, the most valu­able item stolen by the al­leged gun­men was a Toy­ota Land Cruiser. Usu­ally, they left their vic­tims’ ve­hi­cles at the side of the high­way.

Markin would later openly con­tra­dict him­self, telling state ra­dio that the gang was at least partly mo­ti­vated by the de­sire to take the lives of in­no­cent peo­ple. “They were very cun­ning,” he said last year, ahead of the ini­tial court hear­ings for the ar­rested men. “They lived like or­di­nary mi­grant work­ers and were ab­so­lutely docile. But at night, like wolves, they went out to kill.”

At­tor­neys for the sus­pects were ei­ther ap­pointed by in­ves­ti­ga­tors or drawn from a pool of lawyers fa­vored by the se­cu­rity ser­vices. Th­ese state-ap­proved at­tor­neys de­clared their clients were guilty as charged and made no pub­lic ref­er­ence to the ap­par­ent ab­sur­dity of the al­le­ga­tions. How­ever, in con­ver­sa­tion with Newsweek, Irina Zykova, who rep­re­sents one of the sur­viv­ing sus­pects, hinted that there was more to the killings than fi­nan­cial gain. “It’s true that they took hardly any­thing from their vic­tims,” Zykova says. “But you have to un­der­stand—i’m a de­fense at­tor­ney, and for me, it’s eas­ier to work with the case that has been pre­sented than with a more se­ri­ous charge.” She de­clined to go into fur­ther de­tail.

But if the gang mem­bers weren’t killing for profit, then what other ex­pla­na­tion could there be? And why were the Rus­sian au­thor­i­ties so ea­ger to cover up their real mo­tives?

‘White Power! Darkies Out!’

after the shootout at the court­house, i called Natalia Ko­zlova, the au­thor of the Ros­siyskaya

Gazeta ar­ti­cle. As the Rus­sian gov­ern­ment’s of­fi­cial print mouth­piece, the pa­per en­joys good re­la­tions with the se­cu­rity forces and is ex­pected to echo the Krem­lin’s line. I wanted to know if Ko­zlova’s sources in law en­force­ment had lied to her about the GTA gang’s mo­tives. And if not, was there an­other ex­pla­na­tion for state me­dia’s dra­matic shift in tone?

It is ex­tremely un­usual for Rus­sian state me­dia jour­nal­ists to dis­cuss their work with for­eign re­porters, but Ko­zlova de­cided to talk—and had no ap­par­ent qualms about ad­mit­ting there was a cover-up. “In­ves­ti­ga­tors didn’t want to frighten so­ci­ety,” she says. “So­ci­ety doesn’t al­ways need to know the whole truth.” The un­palat­able re­al­ity, Ko­zlova says, is that the killings were in­spired by an ex­plo­sive mix­ture of Is­lamist ex­trem­ism and anger at their hos­tile treat­ment in Rus­sia. “They were mur­der­ing peo­ple on racial, na­tional and re­li­gious grounds,” she says. “It’s likely some of them would have gone on to Syria.”

Al­though it is hard to get ex­act fig­ures, be­tween 1,500 and 4,000 Cen­tral Asian cit­i­zens are be­lieved to have joined Is­lamist mil­i­tant groups in Syria. Many are vul­ner­a­ble to Is­lamist pro­pa­ganda, an­a­lysts say, be­cause they face wide­spread racism, dis­crim­i­na­tion and vi­o­lence in Rus­sia, of­ten at the hands of the po­lice. Cen­tral Asian mi­grants work­ing in Rus­sia have been tar­geted by ISIS on­line pro­pa­ganda videos that ac­cuse them of be­ing “slaves of in­fi­dels” and urge them to join the ji­hadi group in Syria or Iraq.

I asked Diana Tatosova, the at­tor­ney for Fa­zl­it­din Khasanov, one of the four men shot dead dur­ing the court­house break­out, if she had seen any in­di­ca­tion that the gang’s killings were mo­ti­vated by more than rob­bery. She says she has a good re­la­tion­ship with law en­force­ment and had been ap­pointed to the case be­cause in­ves­ti­ga­tors found her “con­ve­nient to work with.”

De­spite her links to the se­cu­rity ser­vices, Tatosova says the GTA gang’s mem­bers were at least partly in­spired by their “ide­o­log­i­cal be­liefs” and a de­sire for re­venge. The high­way killings, she says, were driven by “the mis­taken and prim­i­tive idea that if they are afraid of us, this means they re­spect us.” The shoot­ings had been clas­si­fied as rob­bery-re­lated, she says, be­cause “the In­ves­tiga­tive Com­mit­tee will never say any­thing that could panic the pub­lic.” In­ves­ti­ga­tors did not re­spond to a re­quest from

Newsweek for com­ment, but if the GTA gang was car­ry­ing out a ter­ror­ist cam­paign on the high­ways around Moscow, it’s not hard to see why Rus­sian au­thor­i­ties would be keen to stop the truth from get­ting out.

The killings came at an ex­tremely sen­si­tive time for the Krem­lin. Six months be­fore the first bod­ies turned up on the M4 high­way, hun­dreds of peo­ple chant­ing “White power!” and “Darkies out!” had ram­paged through a south­ern Moscow district after the mur­der of an eth­nic Rus­sian by a man from Azer­bai­jan, a Mus­lim-ma­jor­ity ex-soviet repub­lic. Around half a dozen sim­i­lar ri­ots had taken place in provin­cial Rus­sian towns in the five years lead­ing up to the high­way shoot­ings. In De­cem­ber 2010, thou­sands of ul­tra­na­tion­al­ists had staged a vi­o­lent rally un­der the Krem­lin walls to protest the death of a soccer fan dur­ing a brawl with men from Rus­sia’s largely Mus­lim North Cau­ca­sus re­gion.

The sit­u­a­tion was so se­ri­ous that the Krem­lin called spi­ral­ing racial ten­sions “a threat to na­tional

se­cu­rity.” News that a gang of Cen­tral Asian mi­grants had been mur­der­ing Rus­sians on eth­nic or re­li­gious grounds would likely have sparked na­tion­wide ri­ots and re­venge killings, un­der­min­ing Putin’s claim to have brought “sta­bil­ity” to Rus­sia.

The Krem­lin re­mains hy­per­sen­si­tive about pub­li­ciz­ing Is­lamist at­tacks. On Au­gust 19, after a teenager went on a stab­bing ram­page in Surgut, a city in Siberia, state me­dia made no men­tion of ISIS’S claim of re­spon­si­bil­ity. Rus­sia’s two main na­tional TV chan­nels did briefly men­tion the at­tack, but both re­ports lasted less than half a minute. They cited in­ves­ti­ga­tors who said the as­sailant, a 19-year-old man from Rus­sia’s mainly Mus­lim North Cau­ca­sus re­gion, was suf­fer­ing from psy­chi­atric prob­lems. In­stead of re­port­ing on a clear case of “do­mes­tic ter­ror­ism,” the two state chan­nels de­voted much of their pro­grams to ten­sions in the U.S. fol­low­ing the far-right rally in Char­lottesville, Vir­ginia, on Au­gust 12.

“Rus­sian state me­dia doesn’t want to ad­mit that it’s not just Western coun­tries that are hit by ter­ror at­tacks,” says Rus­lan Le­viev, a prom­i­nent in­ves­tiga­tive blog­ger. “It wants Rus­sians to be­lieve that ter­ror at­tacks in Europe are a di­rect re­sult of more tol­er­ant at­ti­tudes to mi­grants and refugees there.”

Krem­lin Con­spira y

the gta killings stopped with the ar­rests of the mi­grants, but spec­u­la­tion con­tin­ues to run hot as the sur­viv­ing de­fen­dants are set to ap­pear in court again at the end of the year. Not every­one is con­vinced the sus­pects were even re­spon­si­ble for the killings. Ap­par­ent po­lice sketches leaked to Rus­sian me­dia in­di­cated that the as­sailants were white males of Slavic ap­pear­ance. In­ves­ti­ga­tors have not com­mented on the ve­rac­ity of the images, and Newsweek has been un­able to as­cer­tain if they are gen­uine.

Oth­ers say the tac­tics al­legedly em­ployed by the gang, which seemed to pos­sess an un­canny abil­ity to evade po­lice searches, were too pro­fi­cient to be the work of am­a­teur as­sas­sins. “I don’t be­lieve th­ese shoot­ings were car­ried out by th­ese Ta­jik, Uzbek and Kyr­gyz na­tion­als,” says Alyaev, the Fer­gana re­porter. “The killings were all com­mit­ted in an ex­tremely pro­fes­sional man­ner. If this re­ally was the work of a gang of la­bor mi­grants, then Rus­sia’s spe­cial forces would have lo­cated and de­stroyed them in­stantly.”

There are other, more sin­is­ter grounds for sus­pi­cion too. Al­though the al­leged gun­men ini­tially con­fessed to the slay­ings, some later re­tracted their state­ments, claim­ing they had been tor­tured by in­ves­ti­ga­tors into do­ing so. Hu­man rights ac­tivists say tor­ture is com­monly used by Rus­sian po­lice to force in­no­cent peo­ple to ad­mit to crimes they did not com­mit. Cen­tral Asian mi­grants are a par­tic­u­lar target. “I’m al­ways ex­tremely sus­pi­cious when I hear that a Cen­tral Asian mi­grant has been ac­cused of a crime,” says Valentina Chup­kin, the head of Tong Ja­honi, a Moscow-based hu­man rights group. “Rus­sian po­lice don’t be­lieve that Cen­tral Asian mi­grants have any rights at all.”

There are also ques­tions about the lax se­cu­rity at the court­house. Why were only two po­lice of­fi­cers—a 45-year-old man and a 40-year-old woman— tasked with es­cort­ing five of the na­tion’s most no­to­ri­ous al­leged killers to the court­room? And why had they not been cuffed with their hands be­hind their backs, per reg­u­la­tions? “I don’t re­mem­ber a sin­gle case in my en­tire 15-year ca­reer when I was in a court­house lift with five sus­pects at the same time,” Niko­lai Vernik, a for­mer po­lice of­fi­cer who was re­spon­si­ble for es­cort­ing de­fen­dants to court, told Rus­sian me­dia. The sus­pects had all been await­ing trial in the same de­ten­tion fa­cil­ity in Moscow, a se­ri­ous vi­o­la­tion of Rus­sian prison reg­u­la­tions.

Igor Trunov, a prom­i­nent at­tor­ney, says it’s pos­si­ble the men had been en­cour­aged to make a break for free­dom to pro­vide se­cu­rity ser­vices with an op­por­tu­nity to “liq­ui­date” them. Did some­one si­lence the de­fen­dants be­fore they could spill some dark se­crets?

An­var Ulug­mu­radov, the old­est of the sus­pects, cer­tainly wanted to share some­thing in the months be­fore the court­house shootout. “Can I [get as­sur­ances] that noth­ing will hap­pen to me, that no one will harm me…if I say what re­ally hap­pened?” Ulug­mu­radov asked in a pre­lim­i­nary court hear­ing. His fel­low al­leged gang mem­bers, in­clud­ing those gunned down at the court­house in Au­gust, made sim­i­lar ap­peals. To no avail.

“What do you want?” the judge snapped. “The court can’t give you any­thing.”

The sur­viv­ing de­fen­dants have said noth­ing more—at least for now.


ORC D C State-run me­dia down­played re­cent ter­ror­ist at­tacks in Rus­sia, and there is much spec­u­la­tion that Moscow is cov­er­ing up many as­pects of the GTA mur­der spree be­cause it doesn’t want the pub­lic to know the cam­paign was yet an­other...

TOO SP D TR Four GTA sus­pects died amid a gun bat­tle with po­lice while at­tempt­ing to es­cape, left. Some suspect that lax se­cu­rity at the court was part of a con­spir­acy to kill the sus­pects be­fore they faced charges in court.

THE HUNT­ING GROUND The killers placed spikes on roads, usu­ally the M4, above, to set up their am­bushes. The nine ar­rested sus­pects, right, are mi­grant work­ers, all from for­mer Soviet states in Cen­tral Asia.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from USA

© PressReader. All rights reserved.