Minuteman’s finances kept secret by firm
A Texas firm that manages hundreds of thousands of dollars in donations to the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps says it has not been authorized to divulge a detailed accounting of the funds, despiteassurancesbytheMCDC’stop official that it would do so.
Maureen E. Otis — president of American Caging Inc. in Stafford, Texas, an agency hired to collect, depositanddisbursedonationstothe civilian border-patrol group — told The Washington Times that neither MCDC President Chris Simcox nor the group’s board of directors had given her permission to “disclose
Mr. Simcox, who has been criticized by current and former MCDC membersforalackofleadershipand financialaccountability,hadreferred The Times to Mrs. Otis, saying she could “tell you everything” to clear up the concerns.
Instead, Mrs. Otis issued a statementsayingonlythat all Minuteman donations have been “securely collected, counted and deposited” in MCDC bank accounts.
Telephone calls to Mr. Simcox in Phoenix, where he reportedly is on paternity leave, were routed to MinutemanspokeswomanConnieHair in Virginia, who said the organization was not going to release “any unaudited numbers.” She said that an audit will be completed in November and that any release of figures prior to that “is just not going to happen.”
Mary Parker Lewis, a top MCDC consultant, has said the audit seeks to establish MCDC as a tax-exempt, nonprofit organization. She told The Times that MCDC would meet “all its legal obligations” in seeking to organize.
InApril,Mrs.LewisandMs.Hair declined to answer 17 written questions submitted by The Times concerning MCDC finances after severalcurrentandformerMinutemen first raised questions about money coming into the organization. They alsodidnotrespondtoafollow-up list of seven questions in June.
MCDC has not released any financial orfundraisingrecordssince its April 2005 creation to either the public or its members. Disclosure statements promised to The Times by Mr. Simcox in October and later in April were never delivered. He since has accused critics of being racists, anti-Semites and “a small handful of disgruntled people who have been terminated.”
Last month, several Minutemen questioned what happened to donations collected since the group’s first border vigil in Arizona in April 2005. They said they had no idea how much money had been received, how it had been spent or why it was being routed through a Virginia-based charity headed by conservative activist Alan Keyes.
Some of them have since challenged claims by Mr. Simcox that MCDC “spent probably about what we collected” to pay for supplies for Minuteman volunteers on the border, including satellite phones, radios, flashlights, maps, portable toilets, thermal imaging cameras, night-vision cameras, computers, water and food.
Mike Gaddy, a retired Army veteran of Vietnam, Grenada and BeirutwhohelpedorganizetheMinuteman’s vigil asafieldcoordinator, said that if Mr. Simcox spent about what was collected to purchasesuppliesforthevolunteers, he didn’t see any of it.
“An awful lot of the equipment I sawwas donated,” he said.
Other Minutemanmembers confirmed two weeks ago that much of the equipment they used during the border vigils, including night-vision binoculars and Global Positioning Systems, was donated.
Gary Cole, MCDC’s former national director of operations, said hepersonallycollected“tensofthousands of dollars” in donations duringthe30-dayborderwatch in April 2005, but was never told how much money had been collected or where it went.He said he later was fired by Mr. Simcox as a national director “for asking too many questions about the money.”
Last month,Mr.Simcox said $1.6 million in donations had been collected, although he had no documents to verify the claim. He said $1 million went directly to MCDC and$600,000 for a fence on the U.S.Mexico border, all of it handled through the Herndon-based Declaration Alliance, founded and chaired by Mr. Keyes.
Mr.Keyes has endorsed the Minuteman organization as programs of Declaration Alliance and the Declaration Foundation, another Virginia-based charitable organization he heads. He also accused critics of being “decidedly racist and anti-Semitic,” saying they had been removed as members of the Minuteman organization.
For a fee, American Caging manages money collected by nonprofit groups, their telemarketers and direct-responseagencies.Cagingfirms givenonprofitorganizationsthe ability toreceiveanddisbursedonations without having to hire a staff.
In addition to MCDC, the firm’s clients include Declaration Foundation, Declaration Alliance and the Declaration Alliance Political Action Committee. It also has handled funds for Mr. Keyes’ unsuccessful political campaigns, including his failed2004senatorialracein Illinois, for which it was paid $30,530.
American Caging also handles other clients aligned with MCDC, Mr. Keyes and the Alliance organizations, including Diener Consulting Inc., which serves as the Minuteman group’s public-relations arm, as it did in Mr. Keyes’ unsuccessful presidential and senatorial campaigns; and Renew America, a fundraising organization founded by Mr. Keyes that provides a link for donations to MCDC through Declaration Alliance.
Other American Caging clients include Response Unlimited, which makes mailing lists — including the MCDC membership — available to conservative mailers and telemarketers and has an “exclusive contract” with Declaration Foundation; and RightMarch.com, which raised $500,000 for Mr. Keyes’ 2004 senatorialcampaignandhelpsraiseMinuteman donations through a link on its WebpagetoDeclarationAlliance.
Mr. Simcox also serves as “honorary chairman” of the Minuteman Political Action Committee, which says it has spent $350,000 this year to help support several candidates. Mrs. Lewis, who served as chief of staff to Mr. Keyes in his presidential racesandhasbeen affiliated withDiener Consulting and Renew America, is the committee’s secretary.