Misinformation in the news
Mark Twain said, “If you don’t read the newspapers you are uninformed — if you do read the newspapers you are misinformed.” Today, those who rely on the elite media for news of Iraq suffer from both disabilities.
Start with lack of information: The average news consumer probably has no clue that Army Gen. David Petraeus’ new strategy has crippled al Qaeda in Iraq, that Americans and Iraqis now fight side by side against both Sunni and Shia extremists and that eliminating terrorist safe havens and weapons caches has improved security for average Iraqis in regions that a few months ago were snake pits.
As for misinformation, how many people still believe that guards in Guantanamo flushed Korans down the toilet, that U.S. Marines committed a massacre at Haditha and that American soldiers ridicule women disfigured by bombs, run over puppies for sport and desecrate graves for a laugh? All this was reported in such mainstream publications as Newsweek and the New Republic. None of it is true.
Meanwhile, the barbarous violence committed by al Qaeda and the Iranian-backed militias in Iraq is scarcely noted. For example, here’s a story you probably have neither read nor heard: On Oct. 28, in a village 10 miles southwest of Baqubah, U.S. infantrymen came upon a prison run by al Qaeda. In it, according to military spokesmen, they found a hostage, bruised, battered, dehydrated and tied to the ceiling, his arms injured because of how they were twisted behind his back.
He had been kidnapped three days earlier, he said, because “of my brother who is in the Iraqi army. They wanted information and for my brother and me to work for al Qaeda. [. . .] They beat me with cables while holding a gun to my head, but I would not work for them because I would not betray my brother.”
Had he not been rescued, he would have been executed for the “crime” of refusing al Qaeda. Even so, he said, “I would never support them.”
Where can one go to learn what is really happening in Iraq? Michael Yon is a former Green Beret. He has been reporting from Iraq’s battlefields, mostly for his own blog (www.michael-yononline.com). No journalist has revealed more about al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI), including its “reputation for hiding bombs intended to kill parents in the corpses of dead children they’d gutted.”
He has photographed Iraqi and American soldiers as they “disinterred the remains of adults and children” from killing fields. “In one grave,” he noted, “soldiers recovered the heads of decapitated children, some with still partially recognizable remnants of flesh and hair.”
His readers have learned what most would not know from NBC, ABC, CBS, PBS and NPR — why AQI has not won Iraqi hearts and minds: “Between shooting people for using the Internet, watching television or other ‘moral transgressions’ such as smoking in public, AQI’s claim of fundamentalist piety proved to be a thin veneer, quickly eroded by blatant drug, alcohol and prostitute use.”
In perhaps his most haunting dispatch, Mr. Yon reports on meeting an Iraqi official who told him it was al Qaeda’s practice to invite “to lunch families they wanted to convert to their way of thinking. In each instance, the family had a boy” and at some point during the meal “their boy was brought in with his mouth stuffed. The boy had been baked. Al Qaeda served the boy to his family.”
Why have the elite media not covered such atrocities — while spilling barrels of ink over the abuses at Abu Ghraib? In part, perhaps, because the conventional story line is that Iraq is Vietnam redux: Americans are the “occupiers” and anyone who fights them must be “the Resis- tance.” Reporters who dispute that are apt to dine alone.
As to why lower military casualty rates and fewer insurgent attacks are not seen as newsworthy, CNN’s Barbara Starr told media critic Howard Kurtz that it was not yet clear such developments represent “a trend.” But the lines on the graph have been heading south since at least June. Is there any doubt that if U.S. forces had been losing ground for five months it would be a huge story?
The battle of Iraq is not yet over. It is possible al Qaeda and the Iranian-backed death squads could regain the initiative. Iraqi’s fledgling politicians may fail to utilize the opportunity to resurrect their shattered country. But journalists should not assume such outcomes; much less should they wish for them.
Clifford D. May is a nationally syndicated columnist and president of the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies.