Student, car debt quietly added to bailout plan
In the dark of night over the Sept. 2021 weekend when most people were snoozing, the Treasury dramatically expanded its bailout plan to include buying student loans, car loans, credit card debt and any other “troubled” assets held by banks.
The changes, which were included in draft language that also opened the bailout program to foreign banks with extensive loan operations in the United States, potentially added tens of billions of dollars to the cost of the program.
Although it was a major addition to what was already the nation’s largest-ever bailout, it did not become part of the debate between Democrats and the Treasury over details of the program. A Sept. 22 counterproposal by Senate banking committee Chairman Christopher J. Dodd included such consumer loans as well as mortgages, just as the Treasury’s draft did on Sept. 20.
“The costs of the bailout will be significantly higher than originally considered or acknowledged,” said Joshua Rosner, managing director of Graham Fisher & Co., who charged that the Treasury and Federal Reserve have not been “forthright” about the ultimate cost to the public. The plan gives Treasury the discretion to buy the non-mortgage loans and securities in consultation with the Fed.
Conservatives cited the move as a sign that the massive plan to take over bad mortgage debt already is opening the door to further government bailouts.
“Such a large takeover by the government will surely be accompanied by adverse, unintended conse- quences,” said Pat Toomey, president of the Club for Growth, a conservative advocacy group. “Already, other companies and industries are lining up at government’s door asking for their own bailout.”
Treasury Secretary Henry M. Paulson Jr. stressed that the additions were needed to ensure that student loans and credit cards — which have become indispensable to the spending habits and career plans of many Americans — do not become victims of the widening credit crunch.
Student loans, which Wall Street firms packaged and sold to investors just like mortgages, already were hit hard in the widening credit crisis earlier this year, with much of the private loan market disappearing. That forced the government to step in and beef up its direct loan programs for college students.
Many financial analysts feared that the credit card market would be the next domino to fall. Credit card debt also is packaged and sold to investors in complicated “derivative” securities that have become difficult or impossible to sell in recent months.
Investors are spurning the complex securities because they are worried about rising defaults in nearly every category of consumer loans, which reduce the value of individual loans and have made it hard to determine the value of pools of loans that back the securities.
Many of the unsellable loans have been sitting on the balance sheets of banks, forcing them to take losses and preventing them from making further loans.
Richard Berner, chief economist at Morgan Stanley, one of the invest- ment banks that stands to benefit from the loan buyback plan, said the program will help ease frozen loan markets and ensure consumers continue to have access to credit.
“The Treasury proposal is crucial to the credit and risk-taking repair process,” he said, predicting that plan will have “dramatic consequences” in helping to “renormalize” loan markets.
But some financial analysts were not sure whether the massive bailout plan will accomplish its goal of calming markets.
“The credit squeeze gripping the financial market won’t disappear soon as a result of this program. Financial institutions will continue to hoard cash, raise credit standards and increase risk premiums” on loans, said Sung Won Sohn, economics professor at California State University.
Sen. Jim DeMint, a South Carolina Republican who announced his opposition to the bailout on Sept. 22, said he simply doesn’t believe Mr. Paulson when he says it will solve the market problems.
“His predictions have been consistently wrong in the last year,” he said. “It’s a sad fact, but Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this administration. [. . . ] There are much better ways of dealing with this problem than forcing American taxpayers to pay for every asset some investor doesn’t want anymore.”
Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke, Treasur y Secretary Henry Paulson and Christopher Cox, chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, (L to R) arrive Sept. 23 to testify before the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee on the crises facing investment banks and other financial institutions.