FRANKENFISH: GOOD FOR YOUR NATURE
Genetically modified salmon benefits public health and the environment
After 20 years of regulatory scrutiny and political wrangling, the Food and Drug Administration approved a genetically modified salmon, one that scientists say delivers large environmental benefits over existing farmed salmon. Ironically, the salmon, known as AquAdvantage, was opposed by environmental groups.
“This technology was about to be lost,” says Purdue University scientist William Muir, whose research helped the FDA decide the fish by AquaBounty Technologies is safe. “Nobody will invest in technology that can’t be commercialized, and you can’t commercialize without FDA approval.”
The AquAdvantage salmon grows to adult size twice as fast — in two rather than four years — and requires 20% less feed than today’s Atlantic salmon, 100% of which are already farmed.
It also requires no antibiotics, unlike conventionally farmed Atlantic salmon, which public health officials warn can contribute to antibiotic resistance.
“AquAdvantage salmon is as safe to eat as any non-genetically engineered Atlantic salmon, and also as nutritious,” the FDA says.
But Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods, along with other grocery chains, say they will not carry the AquaBounty fish, even as spokespersons from both companies acknowledged that they sell other foods made with genetically modified ingredients or feed. DEMAND GROWTH Ninety percent of the world’s fish stocks are either over-fished or at capacity, but global demand for fish is expected to double by 2050 as the human population grows and poor nations become richer.
AquAdvantage will be the first Atlantic salmon produced on land in warehouses, the method favored by environmental groups. Being produced on land spares natural ocean environments the disruption of large farms complete with pens and motorboats.
Where 8 pounds of feed is required to create 1 pound of beef, just 1 pound of feed is required to create 1 pound of AquAdvantage salmon, the company says.
Replacing mostly imported Atlantic salmon with local production would reduce the pollution from flying salmon in by jet. AquaBounty says it could produce 90% fewer climate-changing carbon emissions.
Environmental groups, including the Natural Resources Defense Council and Sierra Club, hotly oppose FDA approval, pointing to the risk that the fish could contaminate and drive wild salmon populations to extinction. The Center for Food Safety announced it would file a lawsuit to stop “introduction of this dangerous contaminant.”
But Muir, the Purdue researcher who 15 years ago first raised the concern that genetically engineered fish could threaten wild fish stocks, disagreed. What makes the fish great for farming also dramatically lowers its ability to thrive in the wild, he says.
“I won’t argue that a genetically engineered salmon will never find its way into the ocean,” Muir explains. “But there’s nothing in this fish that would last more than a single generation because of its low fitness.” BEYOND SALMON If the newly approved fish is a success in the market, it could be the beginning of a new industry. Muir says the technique of genetically modifying animals offers the possibility of eliminating avian flu, which has killed 440 people, according to the World Health Organization, but which many fear could create a global epidemic killing many thousands.
“We know there are transgenic methods to address avian flu,” Muir says, “but nobody is trying to come up with a solution because you can’t get venture capital and can’t take it to market.”
As for Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods, AquaBounty CEO Ron Stotish was upbeat he could change their minds.
“We not only share all of their environmental concerns, our product addresses them,” he says. “We are hopeful that over time, they will embrace our product.”
The past few years have seen a growing consensus on the safety of genetically modified foods. This year, after Mexican retailer Chipotle announced that it would phase out genetically modified ingredients, it faced a public backlash. That backlash accelerated this month after more than three dozen customers were stricken with the bacteria E. coli from Chipotle restaurants, viewed as a result of the company’s focus shifting from safety and cleanliness to unscientific issues such as modified foods.
Worried about marginalization, mainstream environmental groups have started to tone down fear-based campaigning. They should go further and encourage Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s to carry AquAdvantage, and work with President Obama and Congress to step up public and private research into using genetic modification to benefit public health and the environment.