USA TODAY US Edition

FCC’s Lifeline accused of massive fraud

$1.2 million annually went to fictitious or deceased recipients

- Mike Snider

A new GAO report found massive fraud within the Federal Communicat­ions Commission’s Lifeline program, which subsidizes cellular and broadband service for low-income Americans.

The agency’s three-year audit of the Lifeline program, begun in June 2014 to May 2017, found that more than one-third (36%) of Lifeline customers could not be confirmed as actually eligible for the program. The GAO also found that $1.2 million annually went to fictitious identities or recipients who were dead.

In undercover tests, the GAO found that phone companies approved Lifeline applicants with false personal informatio­n nearly two-thirds of the time (63%).

“A complete lack of oversight is causing this program to fail the American taxpayer — everything that could go wrong is going wrong,” said Sen. Claire McCaskill, D-Mo., in a statement released with the report Thursday. “We’re currently letting phone companies cash a government check every month with little more than the honor system to hold them accountabl­e, and that simply can’t continue.”

Two years ago, in a separate report, the GAO recommende­d the FCC evaluate the Lifeline program. Last year, the FCC did approve a plan for a third-party evaluation by December 2020.

As part of that Lifeline modernizat­ion measure, the FCC also approved Lifeline funds be used for mobile and fixed broadband service. When it was created three decades ago, Lifeline provided assistance for low-income homes to get landline telephone service.

According to the GAO’s new report, Lifeline households numbered 12.3 million during the fourth quarter of 2016, with disburseme­nts of about $1.5 billion.

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, a Republican, said the GAO’s findings confirm weaknesses he voiced concerns about last year during discussion about modernizin­g Lifeline. “Commission staff and the Office of Inspector General have already been developing recommenda­tions to better safeguard taxpayer funds,” he said in a statement. “I stand ready to work with my colleagues to crack down on the unscrupulo­us providers that abuse the program so that the dollars we spend support affordable, high-speed broadband Internet access for our nation’s poorest families.”

Earlier this year, Pai blocked the approval of nine companies from joining Lifeline. The FCC under previous chairman Tom Wheeler had created a national verifier for providers joining the program.

Pai voted against the overall measure — it passed 3-2 on party lines — and in his dissent, he noted that states had done the best job at combating fraud in the system.

During the three-year audit, the FCC and the Universal Ser- vice Administra­tive Co., the notfor-profit organizati­on that administer­s Lifeline, “have taken some steps to enhance controls over finances and subscriber enrollment,” the GAO says.

The FCC has also begun the process to move the $9 billion in Lifeline funds — consumers contribute to this via the Universal Service Fund fees on their phone bills — to the Treasury.

Currently, the Lifeline funds are kept in a private bank account, and the FCC has no control over the funds.

“Since 2005, GAO has recommende­d that the FCC move these federal funds to the U.S. Treasury, but so far no change has been made,” noted McCaskill, who is the top-ranking Democrat on the Senate Homeland Security and Government­al Affairs Committee.

No one is arguing that the program be scrapped, and such a move “would be catastroph­ic for those most in need,” said FCC Commission­er Mignon Clyburn, a Democrat, in a statement. “The answer is not denying access to those who cannot afford connectivi­ty and access to critical services like 911, the next steps should include rolling up our sleeves and addressing any imperfecti­ons that remain.”

 ?? ANDREW HARNIK, AP ?? The FCC’s Lifeline helps some Americans get cellular and broadband service. But Democratic Sen. Claire McCaskill says, “A complete lack of oversight is causing this program to fail the American taxpayer —everything that could go wrong is going wrong.”
ANDREW HARNIK, AP The FCC’s Lifeline helps some Americans get cellular and broadband service. But Democratic Sen. Claire McCaskill says, “A complete lack of oversight is causing this program to fail the American taxpayer —everything that could go wrong is going wrong.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States