Family of slain DNC staffer Rich sues Fox News over speculative story
The parents of slain Democratic National Committee staffer Seth Rich have filed a lawsuit against Fox News Channel seeking compensation for emotional distress from the network’s coverage of a conspiracy theory about their son’s death in 2016.
The suit, filed Tuesday in U.S. District Court in New York by Joel and Mary Rich, also names Fox News investigative reporter Malia Zimmerman and Dallas financial adviser and unpaid network guest contributor Ed Butowsky.
Rich’s family is charging Fox News, Zimmerman and Butowsky with fabricating a story suggesting their son exchanged email with WikiLeaks and that he might have been the source of a trove of DNC emails released after his death.
Rich, 27, was shot to death July 10, 2016, in what Washington, D.C. police say was a random robbery attempt. But conspiracy theorists have tied him to the release of thousands of emails from the Democratic National Committee that hobbled Hillary Clinton’s campaign for president, particularly among supporters of rival Bernie Sanders.
U.S. intelligence analysts — and Clinton herself — believe the Russians used WikiLeaks to publish the hacked emails in July 2016 to interfere with the upcoming elections. On Fox’s The Sean Hannity Show, WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange denied the Russians were the source of the emails.
Rich’s family says the network promoted the theory of their killed son’s supposed involvement, to their distress.
“The network, Zimmerman and Butowsky intentionally exploited this tragedy — including through lies, misrepresentation and half-truths — with disregard for the obvious harm that their actions would cause Joel and Mary,” the suit says.
The case involves a speculative story Fox News published in May 2017 tying Rich to the leak of DNC emails to WikiLeaks which the website then published. The story quoted Rod Wheeler, who had appeared on Fox News as a paid law enforcement and crime analyst, as suggesting Rich had been in contact with WikiLeaks. Subsequently, Wheeler said the story was wrong and the family, according to the suit, asked for a retraction.
The story was discussed on several Fox News programs, but a week later the network removed the story from its website saying it “was not initially subjected to the high degree of editorial scrutiny we require for all our reporting.” Even after that, the network and Butowsky continued to “propagate the sham story and Butwosky continues to harass Joel and Mary (Rich),” the suit says.
Among the prominent purveyors of the debunked Rich story was Hannity, who liberal watchdog group Media Matters for America urged a boycott of due to his continued coverage of the conspiracy theory. In June 2017, Hannity said on Twitter that his “investigation continues” into the affair.
Fox News and Fox Business Network hosts brought up the story into January 2018, the suit says. Neither Fox News nor Zimmerman has issued a clarification about the story, it says.
Fox News declined to comment on the suit citing pending litigation.
The Rich family says in the case they were duped into working with Wheeler as a Butowsky-paid private investigator in the case.
Wheeler has filed his own defamation suit against Fox News. The network has sought a dismissal of the suit, which is pending in federal court.
In the newly filed suit, Mary Rich is quoted saying the severe emotional harm “was like burying (her son) all over again.”
Both parents are exhibiting symptoms consistent with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and other mental health issues, the suit says. Mary Rich is also unable to work.