CAN IVAN TONEY TRANSLATE HIS FORM TO THE TOP FLIGHT?
Since owner Matthew Benham took over Brentford in 2012, the ‘ moneyball’ moniker has stuck with irritating persistence. Stats do play a huge role in the outstanding player trading that’s taken them up two divisions while making a profit on transfers each season, but as co- director of football Rasmus Ankersen told a fans’ podcast recently, identifying talent is often straightforward; the tricky bit is in persuading ambitious players to choose Brentford over bigger clubs. So it was with Ivan Toney.
It was no secret that, at Peterborough, Toney was League One’s best striker. Plenty of teams looked at him, including Fulham and Celtic, but it was Brentford who put down the money – reportedly an initial £ 5m with considerable add- ons – and then managed to coax him into joining their promotion bid rather than making an immediate move to the Premier League.
Toney’s goalscoring statistics at Brentford speak for themselves: he scored 33 goals in 48 Championship appearances last season. Yet it was the multi- faceted nature of his game that really caught the eye. Along with those goals, he contributed 10 assists, while his link- up play was exceptional and he also proved to be a valuable asset for defending opposition set- pieces.
But, as with any striker making their Premier League bow ( Toney’s 10 top- flight minutes with Newcastle in 2015- 16 notwithstanding), there’s a valid question to be answered about whether he can make the step up.
The 25- year- old has the physicality to give elite defenders a tough time, and self- confidence won’t be an issue even if he hits a barren spell. He missed several chances in his first few Bees appearances, before posting a goal total surpassing any other in the second tier since Guy Whittingham in 1992- 93.
Some nit- pickers have pointed to the fact that a third of the Brentford star’s 33 league goals were scored from the spot (‘ Ivan Penal- Toney’ was a barb that irked him), and that all of his strikes came from inside the box ( as if that was somehow a bad thing). However, with Thomas Frank’s charges expected to create far fewer chances per game than they’ve been accustomed to, having a prolific fox in the box is a benefit to be welcomed, not a problem to be solved.
Can the play- off winners thrive at this level? Survival will do for now, at a club previously derided as ‘ just a bus stop in Hounslow’. If the Bees do succeed in staying up, it seems certain that Toney will have had no issues adjusting. He backs himself – so should we.