Geelong Advertiser

Push for critics to lose their voice

- KAREN MATTHEWS Karen Matthews is a former Geelong Advertiser reporter

HERE we go again. The push is on by the federal government to gather support for its proposed voice legislatio­n which would effectivel­y create an extra layer of government focusing solely on Aboriginal Australian­s.

As the debate heats up, supporters scream racism at anyone opposing its introducti­on while those against also say it is racist, but because it divides people based purely on race.

Reality is, that unless and until the government releases details of its voice proposal, it is impossible for anyone to make an informed decision either way.

According to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese the voice consists of some 270 pages.

So where is it?

Why are Australian­s being kept in the dark?

Instead they are being fed a campaign based on nothing more substantia­l than emotion and guilt.

“I believe there is room in people, s hearts to finally recognise First Nations people in our constituti­on,” Mr Albanese said during the week.

In other words, if you don’t vote in favour, you don’t have a heart.

What drivel!

And this, “A voice to parliament will give First Nations people a say in decisions that impact them”. Seriously?

You might say that, if it wasn’t for the fact there are currently 1100 funded organisati­ons and more than 200 programs and services in Australia aimed at advancing Aboriginal Australian­s.

There are also 11 federally elected representa­tives from across parties, the greatest representa­tion of Aboriginal voices in parliament in the history of this nation.

Regardless of the government’s approach to selling the voice, Australian­s are entitled to know the details; matters such as who created it, how would it operate, who would run it, how would those people be selected, what it involved and how much it would cost to implement.

More importantl­y how would it actually assist outback communitie­s still suffering from poverty, alcoholism and domestic violence?

All we have at present is what spills from the lips of smooth tongued politician­s who, I strongly suspect,

particular­ly in the case of inner city elitist activists, stand to make more out of it than those it is purported to help.

And let’s not forget the obscene gravy train called ATSIC which failed miserably and was dismantled in 2004 following corruption allegation­s and litigation involving its chairman Geoff Clark.

As Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price put it, “A core component of our free democracy is the fundamenta­l principle that every Australian citizen is considered equal under the law. Why can’t we do what we fought for, be recognised as Australian citizens in this country, treated equally, not above anyone else and not below anyone else?”

Her comments drew a barrage of unseemly and unwarrante­d namecallin­g from Aboriginal activist Noel Pearson.

Clearly her comments struck a nerve.

The time has come to stop marginalis­ing Aboriginal Australian­s because of their heritage and start treating everyone equally.

And until the federal government releases details of what the voice entails, you’d be a mug to fall for the warm and fuzzy rhetoric of those pushing the ‘Voice’ barrow.

Australia is one country with one people and, at the end of the day my friends, we all bleed red.

 ?? ?? Nationals leader David Littleprou­d and Jacinta Nampijinpa Price voice their opposition to the voice at a press conference outside parliament. Picture: Gary Ramage
Nationals leader David Littleprou­d and Jacinta Nampijinpa Price voice their opposition to the voice at a press conference outside parliament. Picture: Gary Ramage
 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Australia