PRISON FARM BEAT RISDON

THERE has been some recognition of the futility and expense of sending to jail convicted criminals, only to have them reappear for sentencing shortly after they are released. This phenomenon has been with us since the British government was inspired to use Australia as a place to dispose of their own unwanted criminals, but at least the Brits instituted a system of rehabilitation via the ticket-ofleave system, availed of by many of our ancestors to achieve respectability for ever more.

As a former JP, I was privileged to visit institutions including the former Hayes jail farm. What I took away was an understanding that the inmates achieved self worth by understanding that through their produce they were making a contribution, and were appreciative of the rural environment, for many of whom this was a completely novel experience. Discipline was maintained by threatening to return to Risdon any who misbehaved and this was a greatly feared sanction.

At Ashley youth detention centre, I was impressed by the staff, who were aware their principle function was rehabilitation. Nevertheless some said there were occasional instances where an inmate was beyond redemption and isolation the only effective tool.

As to Risdon, it is what it is, an unpleasant place of confinement, which satisfied in every way the perceived popular desire for punishment. There was no sign of educational programs or resources and I can only hope there has been some improvement since my visit.

David Keyes Austins Ferry