The Saturday Paper
Diplomacy is cheaper and better
The decision to buy nuclear-powered submarines is wrong, Michael Costello (“When ineptitude goes nuclear”,
October 9-15). In making such an expensive decision we must consider why we need such a sophisticated weapon. We have no enemies on our borders wanting to invade. Paul Keating in a recent article reiterated what we have known for years: namely we live in the safest country in the world. Keating and others have similarly debunked the “let’s get frightened of China line”. China has not shown any desire to invade any part of Australia. The United States has surrounded China with bases, yet China is called bullying and assertive. Nuclear submarines will create a local arms race and regional tension just went up a notch thanks to this hairy-chested decision. Unfortunately for Mr Costello, just as his article was published, a US nuclear submarine had an accident in the South China Sea. As for Mr Albanese’s decision to meekly follow the Morrison line, I’m with the crowd that calls this cowardice. We would be much better served by soft diplomacy and aid rather than $100 billionplus on exorbitant weaponry. As Australia tries to wrestle with the major challenges of reconciliation and compensation of our First Nations people, the pandemic and the results of climate change, our leaders – both LNP and ALP – have gone down a dead end with nuclear submarines.
– Denis Doherty, Glebe, NSW
Letters are welcome: firstname.lastname@example.org
Please include your full name and address and a daytime telephone number. Letters may be edited for length and content, and may be published in print and online. Letters should not exceed 150 words.