MATTHEW DAVIS

While he may have dumped her in the film, the actor, 43, actually had a real-life crush on Witherspoon while shooting – and even told her so! “She was like, ‘That’s so sweet! OK, let’s work on the scene,’” he recalled. After starring as Warner Huntington III, Matthew Davis was best known for his role in The Vampire Diaries and its spin-off Legacies. He married actress Kiley Casciano in 2018 and the pair welcomed a daughter last year.