"Like all good magic acts, the novel will keep readers on the edges of their seats as they follow the twists and double-crosses that fill the lives of con artists and magicians. The book flawlessly combines magic and suspense in a well-crafted heist story that's sweetly sprinkled with queer romances." — Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
“A lovely, fun, rollicking book that belongs in every library.” — School Library Journal (starred review)
"Hutchinson’s novel has an intriguing setup and historical milieu, and the final trick, which relies on magic, fraud, planning, and friendship, makes for a bravado ending." — Publishers Weekly
"Hutchinson’s evocative writing [...] delights in the reality of found families" — Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books
"Its strength lies in the captivating relationship between Jack and Wil. Now there’s real magic." — Booklist
"Fans of historical fiction, fantasy, and slow-burn romance will find Jack and Wilhelm’s story truly…magical.” — Horn Book Magazine