"The ending is bittersweet but as satisfying as a two-box-of-tissues tearjerker can possibly be (in the realm of juvenile fiction, Schmidt is the master of the emotional gut-punch)." — Horn Book Magazine
"Told in Jack's spare, direct first-person voice, this story's style demonstrates the beautify of simplicity as it delineates the lives of its characters, each as superbly realized as the tumultuous New England setting." — Booklist (starred review)
"The matter-of-fact narrative voice ensures that the tragic plot never overwhelms this wrenching tale of growth and loss." — School Library Journal (starred review)
"A powerful story about second chances, all the more devastating because not everyone gets one." — Publishers Weekly (starred review)
#9 Autumn 2015 — Kids’ Indie Next list