“A highly enjoyable read that will appeal to both readers new to the series and Emily fans alike.”— — School Library Journal
“There’s no doubting the lighthearted but darkly hued creativity on display. Pure black gold.”— — ALA Booklist
“The book dresses up teen-identity issues in midnight-black humor and piles on so much persistent weirdness that oddball outsiders, goths in training, and other subversive types will find themselves positively smirking with glee.”— — ALA Booklist
“[Emily’s] sarcastic, nerdy individualism—with a hint of buried sweetness—will make readers want to spend more time with her.” — Publishers Weekly
