Trump’s request for OPEC to max-out production may backfire
If OPEC is the central bank of oil, then the Trump administration is commanding it to run the printing presses at full speed.
The U.S. State Department took the unusual step of issuing a statement on Wednesday asking the cartel to boost output by tapping the supply buffer it maintains in case of unexpected disruptions. It even gave a figure for how much more the group could pump — 1.4 million barrels a day.
If the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries were to fill this request — and Saudi Energy Minister Khalid Al-Falih said on Thursday that it could — the oil market would be in uncharted territory. Even during the worst crises of the past two decades, including the U.S. invasion of Iraq and Libya’s civil war, the cartel has never been forced to pump flat out.
If U.S. President Donald Trump gets what he wants from OPEC, it might not bring an end to the high oil prices he’s been complaining about for months. U.S. crude futures responded on Wednesday to the news that Saudi Arabia had joined Russia in pumping at close to record levels by rising 1.6 per cent to US$76.41 a barrel — the highest since 2014.
In his 30 years covering the oil market, Jefferies analyst Jason Gammel said he can’t recall ever seeing anything like the State Department request.
“This is the lowest level of spare capacity in the global system relative to demand that I’ve ever seen,” Gammel said in an interview on Bloomberg television. “Spare capacity is moving to a precariously low point” and US$100-a-barrel crude is a realistic possibility, he said.
The U.S. is making these demands for one reason—Iran. The sanctions Trump imposed on the country after tearing up the international nuclear deal have had a more severe impact on its oil exports than many people in the market were expecting. Even Russian President Vladimir Putin says it’s been the main driver of higher prices, and the situation may get worse when sanctions formally start on Nov. 4.
“I don’t think we’re reflecting the full impact of Iranian sanctions as yet in the price,” said Gammel. From early November “the market is probably susceptible to further upside moves in price.”
Trump has made clear that he expects OPEC’s largest producer, Saudi Arabia, to fill the gap in the market created by his Iran sanctions and stop prices going
too high. It’s the only nation that deliberately made investments to maintain a supply buffer and holds almost all of the group’s spare capacity.
Trump has been putting intense pressure on it to pump more, even going as far as to threaten the military alliance between the two nations that’s underpinned the balance of power in the Persian Gulf for decades.
The strategy has worked in one sense.
“Saudi production was below 10 million barrels a day for the first five months of the year; in October we’re producing about 10.7 million,” Energy Minister Al-Falih said at Russian Energy Week in Moscow on Wednesday. “I anticipate that November will be slightly higher,” he said, potentially breaking the production record set in November 2016.
The kingdom is willing to tap all of its spare capacity of 1.3 million barrels a day, if necessary, Al-Falih said on Thursday.
But “whatever it takes” promises like this don’t seem to be reassuring the market. There are echoes of 2008, when prices hit an all-time high above US$140 a barrel and pl edges for more supply only increased the fear of disruptions.
On Wednesday, crude futures surged higher as traders focused on the dangers posed by OPEC’s threadbare safety net.
“Blame speculators if you want, but this is how oil markets work,” PFC Energy analyst Roger Diwan said in a post on Twitter. “Oil markets will read it that spare production is at an all-time low.”