Brookfield, Caisse place $13.2B bet on battery maker
Investment funds position purchase as e-vehicles play but analysts beg to differ
TORONTO The rapid growth of the electric vehicle industry may be drawing headlines, but when it comes to drawing major investments, the internal combustion engine remains on solid footing.
In a deal that highlights the breadth of the traditional automotive industry, two Canadian investment funds on Tuesday announced a US$13.2 billion deal to purchase the leading global manufacturer of lead-acid batteries.
Toronto-based asset manager Brookfield Business Partners and Montreal-based pension manager Caisse de dêpôt et Placement du Québec along with other investors will jointly acquire 100 per cent of Ireland-based Johnson Controls’ automotive business — which shipped 154 million automotive lead-acid batteries in 2017.
Although the buyers described the asset as positioned to benefit from growth in electric vehicles, analysts said its business remains tied to vehicles with internal combustion engines.
“As positioned right now they ’re not an electric vehicle type play,” said Brian Bernard, an analyst at Morningstar Research who covers Johnson Controls.
It is Brookfield Business Partners’ largest acquisition since the unit went public in 2016. The stock rose 1.9 per cent on the Toronto Stock Exchange to close at $49.85.
Johnson Controls has a leading share in the global market for the lead-acid batteries used in traditional vehicles, at about 36 per cent, and has also been growing its absorbent glass mat batteries segment, Bernard said.
The latter segment, known as AGM batteries, allow vehicle engines to shut off at red lights and other stop points, and then quickly restart. That function creates better fuel economy for vehicles, which automotive manufacturers are increasingly seeking, said Bernard. “The growth in those things has been double-digits phenomenal,” said Bernard. “A lot of their investment has been building capacity for that.”
Such batteries are also needed to meet greater power demands as automakers add screens, computers and other functions in cars, he said.
The deal is expected to close by June 30. It will be funded through a mix of US$3.2-billion equity and US$10.2 billion in long-term debt financing, with Brookfield and the Caisse each putting up 30 per cent of the equity and the balance funded by other institutional investors who were not named.
“We are excited to grow our business with the acquisition of power solutions, a global market leader which generates consistent cash flows and profitability,” Cyrus Madon, chief executive of Brookfield Business Partners, said in a statement.
In announcing the deal, the investors stressed the strength of the Johnson Controls’ market leading position, stable cash flows and its diverse customer base.
“The sale of our Power Solutions business will create value for investors by streamlining our portfolio and giving us increased financial flexibility to strengthen our balance sheet, return capital to shareholders and create optionality in our buildings business,” George Oliver, Johnson Controls chairman and chief executive, said in a statement.
Bernard said that although Johnson Controls has a lithium-ion battery facility in Michigan, it’s not a significant player in that market.
Indeed, the company has been moving away from its automotive roots after selling its car-seat unit in 2016. Tuesday’s sale completes its transformation to a “pure-play ” provider of fire, security, climate control and building-management systems.
Chris Berry, of House Mountain Partners, a New York-based adviser to companies that mine battery metals, said that the lithium-ion battery in electric vehicles is not comparable to the lead-acid batteries found in internal combustion vehicles. “The lead acid battery — OK, it’s been around forever,” said Berry. “On the lithium-ion side, you have a number of different chemistries and there’s a tremendous amount of intellectual firepower that’s going into building a lithium-ion battery that will take you further on a single charge.”
In the battle to build the next great lithium ion battery, most of the major players are in Asia, in particular China, said Berry. China is investing billions of dollars every year to develop a supply chain for battery grade material such as lithium and cobalt, and then build facilities that can make batteries.
“They know they’re not going to compete with the West, which has 100 years of internal combustion engine technology,” said Berry, “So they’re saying why not dominate the EV industry?”
Some analysts project electric vehicles could comprise up to 15 per cent of all vehicles in a decade or so, up from around one per cent now, said Berry. But traditional vehicles would still comprise 85 per cent of the market.