MUSK GETS LAST LAUGH
Tesla exceeds dark expectations, ‘squarely on its own two feet now’
NEW YORK It was only a few months ago that Wall Street was bashing Elon Musk’s Tesla Inc.
One analyst called the stock “no longer investable,” citing Musk’s erratic behaviour in tweets and taunts. A short seller bet on a dramatic drop, saying it’s “more and more apparent that Tesla is having difficulties paying their bills.”
But an unexpected thing happened along the way: The company found its footing as an electric-car manufacturer, an achievement masked by Musk’s bluster. Its stunning third-quarter profit picture, boosted by its ability to ramp up production of Model 3 sedans, surprised naysayers, and marked the beginning of a turn in market sentiment.
Tesla’s stock is, somewhat improbably, right back near the highs it reached on the day of that infamous “funding secured” tweet that caused a furious rally before landing Musk in trouble with the SEC.
And so after a year of stomachchurning swings that saw the stock post half a dozen rallies or selloffs of 20 per cent or more, it is up nearly 18 per cent. Not bad at all when you consider that the S&P 500 is down 1.4 per cent on the year.
All of this, of course, could easily shift again at almost any moment, given Musk’s penchant for impolitic remarks and the many operational challenges. But for now at least, Wall Street is bullish once again, expecting Tesla to be profitable and have positive free cash flow in the fourth quarter — accomplishments that would show the company has finally figured out how to produce cars at a stable pace and make money while doing it.
“Was the third-quarter a fluke? Time will tell,” said Roth Capital Partners analyst Craig Irwin. “But the reality is that when you pro- duce 50,000 cars a quarter, that is a big milestone, and you can see these guys are here for the long run. Tesla is squarely on its own two feet now, and learning and well prepared to keep learning.”
Tesla’s stock has always been priced for perfection, and Musk’s Twitter habits weren’t the only roadblocks that investors faced in 2018. As it frantically tried to boost production of the Model 3, Tesla was burning cash at a rapid pace — as much as US$8,000 a minute as it entered the year, according to Bloomberg calculations. Musk acknowledged how dire the problem was in an interview last month, saying the company’s earlier cash bleed had left it just a couple of months away from collapse.
Tesla’s fundamentals are now improving, helped by increasingly efficient manufacturing, strong prices of its cars, and the “slow and disappointing ” competition in the electric vehicle market, Oppenheimer analyst Colin Rusch wrote in a note published on Wednesday. “We believe as TSLA delivers steady cash flow, a new group of investors will begin taking positions, helping drive shares higher.” Tesla shares jumped as much as 1.4 per cent in New York.
Plenty of reasons for skepticism remain. Tesla is still highly levered up and 2019 is going to be an “uphill battle,” Cowen analyst Jeffrey Osborne said. He cited the expiration of electric vehicle tax credits and the lack of pent-up demand for electric cars that helped Tesla in 2018, among other things.
And despite the corporate governance reforms in Tesla’s settlement with the SEC, the company is still at the mercy of Musk to control his behaviour as its public face and chief decision-maker. He responded to an exodus of top executives this year by assuming some of their responsibilities himself, and he bristled in a 60 Minutes interview at the idea that he now has a babysitter supervising him.
But Tesla’s premium valuation today reflects its leadership in electric cars, far ahead of potential competitors. Analysts said they weren’t impressed by two wouldbe electric rivals unveiled this year by Audi and Mercedes-Benz.
General Motors, which is expected to sell about 4.7 million vehicles globally this year, had a market capitalization of US$49 billion through Tuesday. Tesla’s is nearly US$63 billion though it’s likely to sell only 256,000 vehicles.
“It is incredible to me, at the end of 2018, that the major automakers still haven’t figured out how to respond competitively to Tesla,” JMP Securities analyst Joseph Osha said.
“Tesla plausibly can grow at eight-to-10 per cent for a really long time, so it should be valued a lot more highly than companies growing at one or two per cent, which is what the rest of the auto business is growing at.”