Calgary Herald

MPS call for law reform over pandemic pay scandal


The parliament­ary committee that grilled Canada's most powerful grocery executives over their decisions to simultaneo­usly cut pandemic pay bonuses for frontline staff is now calling on the feds to strengthen its rules on wage fixing.

The House of Commons industry committee on Wednesday tabled a report recommendi­ng that the federal government amend the Competitio­n Act to add wage fixing to the list of behaviours that can be prosecuted as criminal offences.

The report's recommenda­tions, if adopted, would expand the competitio­n watchdog 's powers to look at how companies deal with their employees and suppliers, not just their customers.

The industry committee has been following the pandemic pay controvers­y since last year, when it summoned the heads of the top supermarke­t chains — Loblaw Cos. Ltd., Sobeys's parent Empire Co. Ltd., and Metro Inc. — to explain why they cancelled their respective $2-per-hour bonuses for frontline workers on the same day in June 2020.

At that hearing, Metro chief executive Eric La Flèche told the committee that he called the heads of Loblaw and Empire in the weeks leading up to the cancellati­ons to ask when they planned to terminate the bonuses. Both Loblaw president Sarah Davis and Empire chief executive Michael Medline said they didn't answer La Flèche's question. Medline said he insisted on having legal counsel on the call.

“We operate in a competitiv­e environmen­t. We want to treat our employees fairly and be seen to treat our employees fairly,” La Flèche told the committee last July. “The more informatio­n I have on what others are doing, how they are treating their employees and how much they are paying and for how long, is valid informatio­n that I tried to get.”

Davis, meanwhile, sent a “courtesy email” to inform her competitor­s of Loblaw's decision to cut its pandemic pay, “recognizin­g that after telling 200,000 employees, the news would be public immediatel­y.”

All three grocers have said they did not co-ordinate their decisions to cut the bonuses, and strongly denied any wrongdoing in the matter. Each company has implemente­d different bonus programs in the later stages of the pandemic.

Competitio­n Bureau commission­er Matthew Boswell expressed concerns that the top executives at rival grocery chains talked to each other before cancelling the bonus programs.

But he also told the committee that wage fixing, no-poach pacts and other agreements between competitor­s that fix the cost of business inputs are not currently captured by the bureau's “criminal powers.”

The bureau's powers only cover cartel-like behaviours that fix consumer prices, not input prices, due to a 2009 amendment that exempted so-called “buy-side” agreements between competitor­s.

Those agreements — aimed at getting better prices on inputs, such as products or labour — can be benign and even positive for consumers. For example, smaller producers can pool their buying power to get a cheaper bulk price from a supplier.

The Competitio­n Bureau can still pursue buy-side agreements as civil cases when they cross the

line, but it has to prove that they had a negative impact on market competitio­n, which Boswell has admitted is a high bar to meet.

The industry committee's report said the law has a “significan­t gap” when it comes to policing wagefixing agreements.

The report recommende­d the federal government amend the Competitio­n Act to “prohibit cartel-like practices related to the purchase of goods and services, including wage-fixing agreements” between competitor­s.

“Parliament should align Canadian competitio­n legislatio­n with American legislatio­n to criminally prosecute such agreements,” the report said.

Ambarish Chandra, an associate professor at the University of Toronto who focuses on competitio­n and public policy, said Canada's approach to wage fixing is currently “out of the mainstream compared to other countries,” including the U.S.

“Canada badly needs to prohibit wage fixing, which any economist will tell you is just as bad as price fixing,” he said via email. “The fact that the grocery chains even considered discussing wages — let alone actually discussed them and seemingly all cut wages at the same time — is incredible, and the government must make such practices illegal.”

The committee's report also recommende­d a budget increase for the historical­ly underfunde­d Competitio­n Bureau and added its voice to calls for the government to establish a code of conduct that would rein in bully tactics used by dominant grocery players.

Empire welcomed the report, saying it was pleased the committee “accurately reported that Empire did not engage in any discussion­s with our competitor­s” about wages.

Spokespers­on Jacquelin Weatherbee in a statement on Thursday said the company recently sent a letter to the committee “to remind them that we do not, under any circumstan­ces, believe in wage fixing — whether it's legislated or not.”

A Metro spokespers­on declined to comment. Loblaw did not respond to a request for comment.

 ??  ?? Eric La Flèche
Eric La Flèche

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada