‘Unacceptable and offensive’
PM APOLOGIZES AFTER ‘CYNICAL’ REMARK TO WOMAN PROTESTING CONTAMINATION
Prime Minister justin Trudeau came under withering criticism Thursday after a sarcastic putdown of a protester highlighting mercury poisoning in a First nations community.
Trudeau offered a swift apology for his lack of respect, but his comments at a high-end Liberal fundraising event on Wednesday drew widespread condemnation.
“Trudeau’s apology rings hollow while our people are suffering without the care and support that we need,” said rudy Turtle, the chief of the Grassy narrows First nation, the northern Ontario community suffering the impact from mercury poisoning.
Perry Bellegarde, chief of the assembly of First nations, said the prime minister’s comments were “completely unacceptable and offensive,” and called on Trudeau to visit the affected communities in order to “see the impacts of the mercury contamination firsthand.”
Trudeau apologized after a video surfaced
of him making a snide remark to protester Lana Goldberg after she unfurled a banner in front of the prime minister as he addressed a $1,500-a-ticket fundraiser in Toronto.
“Prime Minister Trudeau, people at Grassy narrows are suffering from mercury poisoning,” she said.
as she was dragged out, the prime minister said, “Thank you very much for your donation tonight. i really appreciate it,” drawing applause and laughter from the audience.
On Thursday, Trudeau apologized for his comments to the protester and to the First nations community.
“From time to time i’m in situations where people are expressing concerns or protesting a particular thing, and i always try to be respectful and i always try to engage with them in a positive way,” Trudeau told reporters in Halifax.
“Last night i lacked respect towards them and i apologize for that.”
any funds that the protesters contributed in order to gain access to the event would be refunded, he added.
“They wanted to express their concerns about an issue and i do take that seriously and i apologize to them.”
“i’ve never seen him give that kind of cynical or shut-down response,” said Mark Calzavara, a member of the advocacy group Council of Canadians, who captured the comments on his phone. Calzavara was also raising awareness about the First nations community.
Opposition members of Parliament blasted Trudeau’s comments as being flippant, saying it contradicted the Liberal government’s carefully crafted brand of reconciliatory and progressive politics.
“What a smug, mean, aloof ass,” NDP MP Charlie Angus said on Twitter.
Conservative MP Michelle Rempel called Trudeau “smug” and “arrogant.”
NDP leader Jagmeet Singh tweeted, “Instead of showing respect for people fighting for clean water & funding, Trudeau sides with his rich donors to get a laugh.”
Grassy Narrows has been suffering from mercury poisoning in its local water supply for decades, after an upstream pulp and paper mill dumped thousands of pounds of effluent into the English-Wabigoon river system through the ‘60s and early ’70s.
Meanwhile, a medical treatment centre in the community promised by Ottawa lags behind schedule.
In November, Federal Indigenous Services Minister Jane Philpott announced that Ottawa would provide $170,000 to fund a feasibility study for a long-term treatment centre in Grassy Narrows. Ottawa also promised a treatment centre in the Wabaseemoong, or Whitedog, First Nation that has had similar mercury poisonings.
The facility in Grassy Narrows, designed to hold around 20 beds, was meant to begin construction in the fall of 2018, but has not yet broken ground. One person familiar with the matter said that in discussions with the community in December, Philpott said she expected the project to get underway around June of this year, already months behind its initial start date.
Members of the Grassy Narrows and Whitedog First Nations have been found to have uncommonly high levels of mercury in their blood stream, largely from eating fish from the English-Wabigoon river system. Mercury is often carried in fish, particularly white fish species like walleye, and it “bioaccumulates” — meaning it is often passed down from one generation to the next through childbirth, and is nearly impossible to rid from the body.
Sufferers of mercury poisoning have been known to have learning disabilities, blurred vision and difficulty balancing, among other ailments.
The estimated cost of the Grassy Narrows treatment centre is $17 million, but due to the intergenerational existence of mercury the community is calling on Ottawa to provide maintenance and services to the facility over a 30-year period, for a total of roughly $88 million.
Chief Turtle said the community, about 100 kilometres north of Kenora, Ont., needed to have the money put into a trust to ensure that future governments did not suddenly take away the promised funding.
“I acknowledge Trudeau’s apology, but more importantly he needs to deliver on his government’s promise to build a Home and Treatment Center so our mercury survivors can be cared for with dignity,” Turtle said.