ON THE LINE
Sometimes a product becomes iconic even though it’s not quite perfect—just because it’s so close to it. A quick search for “Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner” in the mega-popular Makeup Addiction subreddit reveals pages of rave reviews about the liner’s opacity, high-shine finish and staying power punctuated by complaints about the long felt tip that can make ultra-precise lines a challenge. Rather than swapping out the eightyear-old liner’s tip (the product is still one of Sephora’s bestselling eyeliners, after all), Stila is adding Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Micro Tip ($29) to its lineup. It features the same tried-and-true formula but has a felt tip that’s a fraction of the size of the original.