Montreal Gazette

Italians have worked hard to build Quebec

- Robert Soroka Professor of marketing, Concordia University Westmount

Re: “An ad that’s insulting to Italians” (Letters, Sept. 14)

The 14th clause of the Canadian Code of Advertisin­g Standards states that “advertisem­ents shall not condone any form of personal discrimina­tion, including that based upon race, national origin, religion, sex or age.”

Clearly this clause was not contemplat­ed when a local television station chose to run an ad produced by an independen­t organizati­on, which, with Italian background music, the obvious cash-in-sock reference, and the closing tag “nettoyons Montreal,” pointed the finger of blame concerning local corruption directly at Italians.

Then again, after our provincial government in effect declared open season on ethnic and religious communitie­s by proposing legislatio­n that abrogates rights once believed to be inalienabl­e, it was only a matter of time before other groups embraced the public vilificati­on of some of Quebec’s subculture­s.

The Italian community has a long rich history in Quebec. Many of the eldest members of this hardworkin­g, robust segment immigrated to Canada with one asset: the ability to work. With no knowledge of English or French and with limited formal education, Italians worked very hard, dedicated to making a better life for themselves and their families. Talk to Italian octogenari­ans and prepare to be astonished by the work they were asked to do, the hours they were asked to contribute, the rate of pay they earned, and the abuse to which they were sometimes subjected. Even more astonishin­g, these same people rarely if ever took a sick day, they shunned public assistance, and they were always upbeat and hopeful, appreciati­ve for what they had. The offspring of these proud, wonderful immigrants became respect- ed, educated profession­als, hard-working labourers, or skilled craftspers­ons. As well, they became committed parents, community leaders, and meaningful contributo­rs to Quebec society.

In short, the Italian community is one of the bedrocks of this province, and has been for generation­s.

There is good and bad within every segment of the population. Any message that assigns unscrupulo­us traits to an entire community should be called out for what it is: xenophobic and racist.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada