Montreal Gazette

Stop being critical of daughter- in- law

- KATHY MITCHELL AND MARCY SUGAR

Dear Annie: My son and daughter- in- law have two beautiful children, ages 6 and 7. Since my retirement, I’ve taken care of the children while the parents work. I also gave them a large sum of money for the down payment on their home in an area with good schools.

Over the past couple of years, I have noticed that they spend money extravagan­tly and have failed to keep up with the maintenanc­e of their house. Last month, they informed me that they may need to sell the place, because they find it difficult to keep up with expenses, even though I know their income is perfectly adequate to cover all of their household costs.

I have a real estate background and explained to them that the market has declined, making the value of the house less than what they owe on it. I became quite impatient and almost angry, suggesting that they seek financial guidance to get back on track. In addition, I am emotionall­y and physically drained when caring for the children, as they do not keep the house clean and piles of dirty clothing can be found all over. At times, I have done the wash and cleaned the house, simply so I can tolerate being there. I am concerned about my grandchild­ren in that environmen­t.

I have spoken to my son and he says he won’t confront his wife on these issues because he wants to choose his battles. My daughter- in- law does not seem to mind living in a dirty, disorganiz­ed environmen­t. I feel she is negligent and not providing the proper care and nurturing for my grandchild­ren. She only works part- time and could do these things.

Should I bring the kids to my house instead? I am trying to be positive, but it is becoming difficult to maintain a relationsh­ip with her. Need Cleanlines­s

Dear Need: We cannot caution you enough that you are risking your relationsh­ip with your son and grandchild­ren by being so critical of your daughterin- law. Unwashed clothes and dishes in the sink do not constitute a danger to the children. The fact that her job is part- time does not mean all the responsibi­lity for the house falls on her shoulders. Your son can do laundry, too, and the children are old enough to pick up their clothes. It may not be up to your standards, but that’s not your decision.

Here’s our advice: If you can bring the kids to your home, do so. You will be calmer. But do not say anything to your son or daughter- in- law about the cleanlines­s of their house. Your advice that they seek financial counsellin­g is excellent and we hope they take it, but they are less likely to listen to you if you are impatient, angry and overly critical. Tread lightly.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada