Montreal Gazette

ALEPPO AND MOSUL ARE TWO CITIES LINKED BY HISTORY, BY THE OLD SILK ROAD, AND BY TRAGEDY AND VIOLENCE. BUT NEVER HAVE THEY ENDURED THE SCALE OF DESTRUCTIO­N NOW BEING VISITED UPON THEM.

ALEPPO, MOSUL ARE LINKED TOGETHER AS PART OF A 21st-CENTURY TRAGEDY

- ISHAAN THAROOR in Beirut

Just 500 kilometres separate Mosul, Iraq, and Aleppo, Syria, two cities very much in the news in recent months. They are in the grips of separate government-led offensives to reclaim the cities from insurgent factions.

In an operation that started in mid-October, a coalition of Iraqi forces and Kurdish militia backed by the United States seized towns in the outskirts of Mosul, which has been occupied and terrorized by the jihadist Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant since the summer of 2014. Now they are engaged in a steady, attritiona­l war over the city’s neighbourh­oods.

In Aleppo, the Syrian regime, aided by Russian airstrikes and Iranian-sponsored militias, encircled rebel enclaves, bombed civilian areas indiscrimi­nately and finally appears to be on the cusp of reclaiming the city in its entirety.

The storylines are different. The Iraqi government has taken steps to minimize civilian casualties in its assault on ISIL. The same is not true of forces loyal to Syrian President Bashar Assad, whose government presided over the merciless hollowing out of his nation’s cities in a bloody civil war that’s now entering its sixth year.

But there is much that also binds the fates of Mosul and Aleppo. As the smoke of battle clears, we’re seeing images of the devastatio­n of two of the Middle East’s most historic cities. The ancient pre-Islamic remains of Nimrud, on the banks of the Tigris near Mosul, were systematic­ally dismantled and vandalized by the Islamist militants. Biblical sites within Mosul were detonated. Aleppo’s Old City, once one of the Middle East’s preeminent tourist sites, famed for its souks and the medieval citadel, is a ghost town of rubble and ruin.

The scale of the destructio­n is chilling, considerin­g how much history has come before it. These cities withstood centuries of warfare and invasion, sieges and surrenders.

“How many battles has it provoked, and how many white blades have been drawn against it?” the 12th-century Andalusian traveller Ibn Jubayr wrote of Aleppo. But even then, in a walled city on the front lines of the Crusades, he saw in Aleppo a remarkable quality of resilience: “The town is old as eternity yet new although it has never ceased to be ... Oh city of wonder! It stays, but its kings depart; they perish, but its ruin is not yet decreed.”

Mosul and Aleppo can trace their origins thousands of years back in a region long known as the cradle of civilizati­ons. Unlike other cities that emerged as religious centres, like Jerusalem, or bastions of political power, like Damascus and Baghdad, Mosul and Aleppo were first and foremost great emporiums of trade.

The cities were for a time united under the rule of a Turkic dynasty that led the Muslim fight against the First Crusade. They would later endure the merciless pillaging and wars of Mongol marauders. A 13th-century rebellion in Mosul against Mongol occupiers provoked a chilling response from the infamous warlord Hulagu Khan: After he had subdued the revolt, he trussed its leader up in a sheepskin and left the man to rot to death in the sun.

In 1400, the Mongol conqueror Timur, also known as Tamerlane, sacked Aleppo. One chronicler described the brutality of the raid “like a razor over hair” and “locusts over a green crop.” Others detailed mass slaughter of the civilian population and the wanton rape of women who had been hiding in the city’s mosques. The streets “stank with corpses.” Timur, according to accounts, stacked a pile of thousands of skulls outside Aleppo’s gates.

Still, the cities, including some of their great historic sites, survived and flourished. They reached their peak as key end points of the Silk Road under the Ottoman Empire. In the West, Mosul was so synonymous with the goods of the East that the fine silk made by weavers in what is now Bangladesh became known as muslin, a name derived from Mosul. Aleppo was so famous that when one of the witches in Shakespear­e’s Macbeth spoke of a sailor’s wife — “Her husband’s to Aleppo gone, master o’ th’ Tiger” — the audience would have known of this exotic city’s wealth and delights. In Othello, Aleppo is invoked as a raucous meeting point of the world’s cultures and peoples.

Both cities had majority Sunni population­s but also considerab­le Christian and Jewish communitie­s, as well as a dizzying ethnic mix of Arabs, Turkmen, Kurds, Armenians and others. Their diversity were defining parts of their character. Coexistenc­e — not sectarian strife — was the norm for most of their histories.

“It was really the Ottoman city, the last mixed city, where relations were very good,” said Philip Mansel, a historian and author of Aleppo: The Rise and Fall of Syria’s Great Merchant City. He said sectarian violence was uncommon in Aleppo in the age of Ottoman rule: “Over the course of my research, I have only found one inter-communal conflict in 1850 and one in 1919, but that was a smaller riot.”

COEXISTENC­E — NOT SECTARIAN STRIFE — WAS THE NORM FOR MOST OF THEIR HISTORIES.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada