GOING WITH A GOOD FLOW
Seasoned architect discusses how to make most of a floor plan, shares insight on renos
Carmel Greer is an architect and the owner of District Design, a Washington, D.C.-based design firm. She specializes in residential and boutique commercial projects. Her practice includes plenty of work in historic urban houses. One of her favourite challenges, she says, is working in tight urban spaces. Greer chats about dealing with rowhouse renovations and more.
Q What is the biggest mistake you see homeowners making on a rowhouse renovation, especially those renovating for the first time?
A I always suggest that clients focus on getting the overall plan and flow of spaces exactly right. Those are the things that are impossible to change with ease later. You can change a faucet, but a floor plan, not so much. Sometimes a client will be more focused on changing the finishes in a space rather than the space itself. If the kitchen is in the wrong place, changing the colour of the cabinets will go only so far. We also focus a lot on getting light into the middle of rowhouses. Kitchens need cabinetry, which can block light, so sometimes the kitchen works best in the middle of the rowhouse.
Q How do you maximize light in rowhouses, especially if there’s a house on either side of it?
A The key is to be able to see light above and light ahead. To that end, we usually try to open up the stairwell or a portion of a floor so that light can stream down through a skylight. Opening up the rear of the house and maximizing glass is also key. Even if you cannot add a lot of glass to the rear facade, just seeing a glimpse of the outdoors when you enter the home can make a big difference. This might require moving a wall or enlarging an opening.
Q I live in a co-operative apartment building and want to renovate the bathroom. My project will involve bumping out a wall, moving the toilet, converting the shower and running a waterline from the bathroom through a bedroom through an exterior wall to create an outdoor spigot for my terrace garden. Do I need an architect to plot this or can I make do with a contractor or a design/ build firm? The board has to approve the work.
A You will need a building permit, so you will need someone who can draw the scope of work. That does not necessarily need to be a full-fledged architect. Projects such as yours are hard because they used to be able to be accomplished with a reputable contractor/plumber and common sense but now require real drawings. Q We love our rambler, but we’d also love to update two bathrooms. We’d like to expand a kitchen and add a garage with storage and an upstairs suite. We’re also considering adding a second level or attic. Finally, we may need to update or replace the baseboard heating. Given that we live in a tear-down neighbourhood, we are hesitant to sink too much money into it if it’s a future teardown. No matter how much value we add, it probably would not be worth as much as a new build in the neighbourhood. Do you have advice on where to begin with the decision of renovating, tearing down or moving? Should we engage an architect, a builder or a realtor? A This is a dilemma I hear very often. I don’t love tearing down a perfectly good house. That said, there is sometimes a real point of diminishing return. We are doing a new house where the tear-down had a failing foundation and was coated in asbestos inside and out — that was an easier decision. I think the right answer will depend on how long you intend to live in the house. If you think you may need to move next year for work, you’ll need to approach things differently than if this is a “forever” home.
Q We have a screened porch on the east side of our house. It has some old, low-pile carpet and a high ceiling that I’ve painted a light blue. Despite the brighter ceiling and a string of lights, it remains dreary. What do you suggest I do to make it more inviting?
A We sometimes put skylights in porches. You could also replace the porch roof with a trellis, though that would not be nice in the rain. A less architectural option would be to use bright and intense colour for some of the furnishings or pillows.
Q We moved into a modest condo with ugly green granite around the gas fireplace. Is there a way to resurface it (paint, tile, etc.) instead of replacing the granite?
A It’s almost always better to replace the surface you don’t like. If you paint over it, it will probably ultimately peel and chip. If the stone is polished, you could have it honed to tone it down.
Q We redid our kitchen 12 years ago in a dark wood. The cabinets were custom and are of good quality. But the finish is rubbing off at the most common touch points and edges. Should they be replaced or refinished?
A An excellent painter could repaint or refinish them. “Excellent” is the key word — it is tricky to repaint kitchen cabinets in a manner that will be durable.
Q Can you tell me the pros and cons of refrigerators that are counter-depth vs. more traditional fridges that seem to always stick out beyond counters?
A I often tell clients that nothing good happens in the back six inches of a refrigerator. I prefer counter depth. The deep refrigerators look like behemoths, particularly when space is at a premium. I suggest a taller refrigerator instead.
Q We’ve been considering taking down an interior wall to combine the kitchen and dining rooms for a larger, open-floor plan and extra kitchen space. My one concern is that the “workhorse” part of the kitchen (sink, fridge and cooktop) would then be much closer to the main living area of the house. I worry about cooking smells, noises in the living room, etc. Are there any guidelines for determining whether this is too close for comfort? Should the couch and TV be a certain distance from the cooktop and appliances, for example?
A I think it depends on how you live. If you are a somewhat messy cook, you may not want a fully open kitchen. You can achieve a sense of openness by having visual connections between rooms without taking all the walls down. I don’t think there is a rule of thumb — it’s more about your needs, habits and lifestyle.
Q We live in a mid-1960s split-level home. Our entry has French doors, and we’re wondering whether it makes sense to replace them with a single door with sidelights. Also, we’d like a doorway that harks back to when our home was built. What’s a good style for the doorway?
A You could do a big pivot door for a dramatic entry experience. I generally prefer a double door to a single door with sidelights. Depending on the vintage and style of your house, you could do something amazing and unexpected with the colour of your door, too. The great thing about a bold door colour is that it’s relatively easy to change the colour if you decide your choice no longer suits you.